Critically, examine the constitutional provisions which ensure the independent judiciary in India.
The Constitution gives the judiciary several protections, but a critical look shows that some of them work better than others and that the main controversies have been about appointment, transfer and the age of retirement.
Appointment. Articles 124(2) and 217(1) call for "consultation" with the Chief Justice of India. In S P Gupta v Union of India the Court read consultation to mean that the executive had the last word, but in the Second Judges case (Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v Union of India, AIR 1994 SC 268) it reversed that and held that the opinion of the Chief Justice, formed collectively with his senior colleagues, has primacy. Ahmadi J, dissenting, said that this amounted to rewriting the Constitution and compared the collegium to an oligarchy in the guise of independence. The system has been criticised on other grounds also. The Law Commission in its 121st Report had asked for a National Judicial Commission, and attempts in 1990 and 2003 lapsed. F S Nariman, who argued the Second Judges case successfully, later called it a case he would prefer to have lost, saying that there was too much ad hocism and no consistent and transparent process of selection. The Ninety-ninth Amendment was struck down by a majority of four to one. A critic could say that the Court has in effect made the judiciary the appointing body, a result that the text does not clearly require, and that the Court itself has acknowledged the ambiguity in the Second Judges case on whether judicial primacy is necessarily required to secure independence. On the other side, the executive's record shows the need for protection. The convention of appointing the senior-most judge as Chief Justice was broken twice, in 1973 when Ray J was appointed over three senior colleagues who had been in the majority in Kesavananda Bharati, and in 1977 when Beg J was appointed over Khanna J, who had dissented in ADM Jabalpur.
Qualifications. Article 124(3) allows the appointment of a distinguished jurist, but in practice no jurist has ever been appointed to the Supreme Court, although a number of lawyers have been appointed directly from the Bar.
Tenure and age. The retirement age gives the Court a regular infusion of new talent, but may remove judges just when they are becoming effective constitutional judges. It has been suggested that the age for the Supreme Court judge should be raised to 70. The Law Commission also suggested raising the age for High Court judges to 65 and banning practice after retirement; the age was raised only from 60 to 62 and the ban was not imposed for High Courts.
Pay. The Constitution protects pay from reduction, but the salary of judges has been described as at the lower end compared with the salary of civil servants and legislators. Post-retirement benefits have also been added by law.
Removal. The process in Article 124(4) is stringent, which protects judges. The same stringency means that removal is possible only through a long parliamentary and inquiry process, so a critic can say that it offers little day-to-day accountability for misbehaviour that falls short of what can be proved to that standard.
Transfer. Transfer is the weakest link. Sixteen High Court judges were transferred during the Emergency, and it was widely believed that this was a punishment for judgments against the government. In Union of India v Sankalchand Himatlal Sheth, the majority (3:2) held that the consent of the judge is not required, though consultation with the Chief Justice has to be full and effective. In S P Gupta, Bhagwati J remarked that the so-called safeguard of consultation had proved of no avail. The later position has improved, because the Second Judges case made the opinion of the Chief Justice of India binding.
Subordinate judiciary. The Constitution has insulated the lower courts from executive control through Articles 233 to 235. The Court has also required that district judges be drawn from the judicial service (and the Bar), and not from the police, excise or other executive services.
On balance the Constitution's provisions are strong in tenure, pay and removal, and have been strengthened by the Court on appointment and transfer, but they depend on the integrity of the process and on transparency, which the system still lacks.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
