Constitutional LawUnion and State Judiciary 03 August 2026· 3 min read

    Do you think that if a judge of one High Court is transferred to another High Court it will adversely affect the independence of judiciary? If it will, on what reasons.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    It can, and that is why the power of transfer has been controversial. Article 222(1) allows the President to transfer a judge from one High Court to another after consultation with the Chief Justice of India. As the Article is worded, neither the consent of the judge is necessary nor is the opinion of the Chief Justice binding on the government.

    The reasons why independence may suffer. First, the power may be used as a punishment. During the Emergency of 1975, sixteen High Court judges were transferred from one High Court to another, and it was widely believed that this was done to punish those who had given judgments against the government. The Supreme Court in Sankalchand Himatlal Sheth found that the record did not bear out the claim that the transfers were for the purpose of national integration, and Bhagwati J said in S P Gupta that the transfers had been made as punishment. Secondly, a transfer is inconvenient and carries a stigma, which can put pressure on a judge who knows that a decision against the government could result in a distant posting. Thirdly, a judge who has to be consulted only in form has little protection: Bhagwati J remarked that the so-called safeguard of consultation with the Chief Justice of India had proved of no avail.

    What the Court has done. In Union of India v Sankalchand Himatlal Sheth, the Court divided 3:2. The minority held that "transfer" means only a consensual transfer. The majority held that consent is not necessary, but that consultation with the Chief Justice of India has to be full and effective, that his opinion is entitled to the greatest weight and that any departure needs strong and cogent grounds. The majority also said that the proposal should be initiated by the Chief Justice of India, that transfer must be only in public interest and an exceptional measure, and that it should not be a punishment, since a judge may be punished only under Article 217(1) read with Article 124(4). In S P Gupta v Union of India, the majority again held that consent is not required, but said that the power is subject to public interest and effective consultation, and that a transfer is justiciable and may be quashed if it is not in public interest, if there was no full and effective consultation, or if the Chief Justice's opinion was brushed aside without cogent reasons. A transfer with an oblique motive, such as a judge not toeing the line of the executive, is outside Article 222. In the Second Judges case, Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v Union of India, AIR 1994 SC 268, the Court held that consent is not needed, and that the Chief Justice of India's recommendation on transfer is binding on the executive. A transferred judge can be transferred again.

    Conclusion. Transfer does not by itself harm independence if it is made on the initiative and judgment of the Chief Justice of India, for reasons of public interest such as national integration or improving the functioning of the courts. The Law Commission supported bringing in some judges from outside the State for that reason. But it can harm independence if the executive uses it to punish or to pressurise. The safeguards the Court has created, in particular the primacy of the Chief Justice of India's opinion and the justiciability of a mala fide transfer, are meant to address that danger.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.