Contract ActVoidable Contracts and Void Agreements 13 May 2026· 3 min read

    A agrees with C to print libellous matter against C and B pays Rs. 500 as advance, promising Rs. 10,000 more after printing. B claims back advance paid

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The agreement in question involves printing libellous matter.

    1. Legality of the Object: The question is read as 'A agrees with B to print libellous matter against C', and the object of the agreement is the printing of libellous matter about C. Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, states that the consideration or object of an agreement is unlawful if, among other things, it is fraudulent or the court regards it as immoral or opposed to public policy. Printing libellous matter is against public policy and potentially involves fraud or is immoral, as it harms a person's reputation. An illustration under Section 23 shows that an agreement for the division of gains acquired by fraud is void because its object is unlawful. By extension, an agreement whose object is to commit libel is also likely to be considered void for having an unlawful object.

    2. Effect of Unlawful Object: An agreement where the object or consideration is unlawful is void. A void agreement is not enforceable by law.

    3. Recovery of Money Paid under a Void Agreement: B paid Rs. 500 as an advance for this agreement. The question is whether this advance can be claimed back. Section 65 of the Indian Contract Act addresses the obligation of a person who has received an advantage under a void agreement. Section 65 states that when an agreement is discovered to be void, or when a contract becomes void, any person who has received any advantage under such agreement or contract is bound to restore it, or to make compensation for it, to the person from whom he received it.

    An illustration relevant to this principle, though not directly on libel, is where money paid in consideration of a promise that was void from the start must be repaid.

    Furthermore, the recovery of money paid in advance for an illegal transaction where the plaintiff is not relying on the illegal transaction but seeking to recover the money by putting the parties back in their original position. The case of Hermann v Charlesworth ((1905) 2 KB 123) is cited, allowing the recovery of money paid as advance in such cases, because the plaintiff is not relying on the illegal transaction.

    Applying this to the scenario:

    • The agreement to print libellous matter has an unlawful object.

    • Therefore, the agreement is void.

    • B paid Rs. 500 as an advantage under this void agreement.

    • Under Section 65, the person who received the Rs. 500 (presumably A, or possibly C if the money went directly to the printer) is bound to restore it to B. This is supported by the principle that money paid under an illegal transaction can be recovered if the illegal purpose has not been fully carried out. Since the query mentions a promise of Rs. 10,000 more after printing, it implies the printing might not have occurred yet. If the libellous matter has not been printed, the illegal object has not been fully achieved.

    Therefore, B can sue to recover the Rs. 500 advance paid. The void nature of the agreement under Section 23 entitles B to the restitution of the benefit provided, as per Section 65. On recovery of money paid under an agreement of this kind where the unlawful purpose has not been carried out, refer Kedar Nath Motani v Prahlad Rai (AIR 1960 SC 213).

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.