A and B are friends. B treats A during illness without payment. A promises B's son X to pay Rs. 1,000. A unable to pay. Can X recover?
The general rule under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, is that "An agreement without consideration is always void". Section 25 of the Act begins by stating that "An agreement made without consideration is void...". Consideration is regarded as the "price for which the promise of the other is bought" and forms the "very foundation" of a contract.
However, Section 25 provides specific exceptions to this general rule, where agreements made without consideration can still be valid and enforceable. The exceptions include:
Agreements made on account of natural love and affection between near relatives, provided they are in writing and registered.
Promises to compensate someone who has already voluntarily done something for the promisor (Past Voluntary Service).
Promises to pay a debt that is barred by the law of limitation, if made in writing and signed.
Some other instances, like a contract of agency or remission of performance by the promisee, where consideration is not required.
The above scenario involves a past voluntary service rendered by B (treating A during illness without payment) and a subsequent promise made by A to X (B's son) to pay Rs. 1,000. This situation brings into focus the second exception under Section 25(2): a promise to compensate for past voluntary service.
Section 25(2) makes a promise enforceable if it is "a promise to compensate, wholly or in part, a person who has already voluntarily done something for the promisor". This covers a promise to pay for a past voluntary service which was rendered "without any request or promise" and for which there is a subsequent promise to pay. The service should have been rendered voluntarily and for the promisor only. Illustrations often involve promising to pay someone who found and returned a lost item or supported a person's infant son.
However, the promise in the present scenario is made by A to X (B's son), not to B (the person who rendered the service). This raises the question of whether the promise is enforceable by X under Section 25(2). The specific illustration addresses this scenario:
"A and B are friends. B treats A during A's illness. B does not accept payment from A for the treatment and A promises B's son, C, to pay him Rs. 1,000. Here, C, to whom the promise was made, did nothing for A, so A's promise is not enforceable."
The promise made by A to X is not enforceable by X. The reason is that X, the person to whom the promise was made, did nothing for A. While B rendered a voluntary service, the promise to compensate for that service was made to a third party (X) who did not perform the service.
The obstacle is not privity. A's promise was made to X, so X is the promisee, and Section 2(d) allows consideration to move from "the promisee or any other person". The defect is the absence of consideration. B's treatment of A was a past voluntary service, not rendered at A's desire, so it cannot be the price of a fresh promise; and the exception in Section 25(2) protects only a promise to compensate the person who himself did the act (here B). X did nothing for A, and A made no promise to B to which Section 25(2) could apply.
A's inability to pay the Rs. 1,000 is a separate matter concerning the possibility of recovery once a legal obligation is established. However, in this case, the promise itself is not legally enforceable by X because it does not meet the requirements of Section 25(2) as interpreted by the illustration provided.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
