Family LawHindu Uncodified Law 19 May 2026· 5 min read

    A and his sons B and C were Mitakshara coparceners. C separated, then A dies leaving widow W and daughter D. Claims analysis.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Setting the Stage: The Coparcenary and Its Disruption

    To begin with, A, B, and C form a Mitakshara coparcenary, each holding an undivided one-third interest in the joint family property. The coparcenary, as the Supreme Court described it in State Bank of India v. Ghamandi Ram (AIR 1969 SC 1330), is a quasi-corporate body in which no member can predicate a definite, fixed share until partition is sought.

    Then C separates. The moment C demands partition and receives his share, a severance of status occurs between C and the rest of the family. C takes his one-third share as his separate property and walks out of the coparcenary. We assume that C separated before A's death. What remains is the residual joint family property, and all fractions below are fractions of that property. C is, from this moment, a separated coparcener, a stranger, in the coparcenary sense, to the remaining family. The daughter D is a coparcener by birth under Section 6(1) as substituted in 2005 (Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma, (2020) 9 SCC 1), and her position must be factored in throughout.

    A Dies: Opening of the Question

    When A dies, the law that springs into operation is Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, as amended in 2005. Under the amended provision, the doctrine of survivorship stands abolished for coparceners dying after 9th September 2005. The amended section mandates that when a Hindu dies having an undivided interest in Mitakshara coparcenary property, his interest shall devolve not by survivorship, but by testamentary or intestate succession, after effecting a notional partition immediately before the moment of death.

    The first task, therefore, is to ascertain what A's share would have been had a partition taken place just before his death.

    The Notional Partition: Computing A's Share

    At the time of A's death, the coparcenary in existence consists of A, B, and D, D having become a coparcener by virtue of Section 6(1) of the amended Act, which confers upon the daughter of a coparcener the same birth right in coparcenary property as a son. C has already separated and holds no interest in this coparcenary.

    C separated before A's death, so he holds no interest in the coparcenary and takes no part in the notional partition. Explanation II to the old Section 6 barred a separated heir from claiming under the proviso, but it belonged to the pre-2005 text and cannot be applied to the section as substituted.

    The notional partition is therefore effected among A, B, and D. Under the wider approach affirmed by the Supreme Court in Gurupad v. Hirabai (AIR 1978 SC 1239), the widow W is also entitled to be allotted a share equal to that of a son at the time of the notional partition, since she would have received such a share had a real partition taken place. The coparcenary thus notionally divides among A, B, D, and W, four shares. A's share comes to one-fourth (1/4) of the total remaining joint family property.

    This one-fourth share, once demarcated through the fiction of notional partition, becomes A's separate property available for succession under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

    Distribution of A's Share Among His Heirs

    A has died intestate. W (widow), D (daughter), B (surviving son) and C (son, now separated) all figure in Class I of the Schedule to the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. A son does not cease to be a Class I heir because he has separated. The rule under Section 8 is that Class I heirs inherit simultaneously, and under Section 10 the widow takes one share and each son and daughter one share.

    A is thus survived by four Class I heirs: W, B, D and C. On this view his one-fourth share divides equally among them:

    • W (widow) takes 1/4 of 1/4 = 1/16 of the total property

    • B (son) takes 1/4 of 1/4 = 1/16 of the total property

    • D (daughter) takes 1/4 of 1/4 = 1/16 of the total property

    • C (son) takes 1/4 of 1/4 = 1/16 of the total property

    B also takes his own share of 1/4 in the notional partition, so his total is 1/4 + 1/16 = 5/16. W and D likewise hold 1/4 + 1/16 = 5/16 each, and C holds 1/16, all as tenants-in-common. It bears emphasis here that the shares inherited by W, B, D and C from A's estate are held by them as tenants-in-common and not as joint tenants, they do not revive into any fresh coparcenary among themselves. As the Supreme Court made plain in Uttam v. Saubhag Singh (AIR 2016 SC 1169 : (2016) 4 SCC 68), once the coparcenary interest devolves by succession under Section 8, the property ceases to be joint family property in the hands of the heirs, and they hold it as tenants-in-common.

    The Position of C

    C has no claim as a coparcener, having separated before A's death. As A's son, however, he is a Class I heir, and A's share in the residual property, once fixed by the notional partition, passes under Section 8 to all Class I heirs. This is the better reading of the substituted section, though the point is not settled by authority. If C were held excluded, B, D and W would take one-third each.

    The Claims of W and D: Their Absolute Ownership

    Both W and D hold their respective shares as absolute owners. Section 14 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, has abolished the concept of a woman's limited estate. Any property that vests in a female Hindu, whether by succession or partition, is held by her as a full owner with untrammelled powers of disposal. W's and D's shares are therefore not qualified or limited interests, they belong to them absolutely, to sell, gift, bequeath, or otherwise deal with as they see fit.

    W also retains the right to enforce her share. As the Supreme Court recognised in Gurupad v. Hirabai, a widow who inherits under the proviso to Section 6 is entitled not only to her share in the estate of the deceased coparcener but also, if she chooses to seek partition of the remaining joint property, to assert both her inherited interest and her share as she would have received in a real partition, the two sources of entitlement being cumulative, not alternative.

    Summary of Final Shares

    PersonBasis of ClaimShare in Total Property
    B (son)Notional partition + inheritance from A1/4 + 1/16 = 5/16
    W (widow)Notional partition + inheritance from A1/4 + 1/16 = 5/16
    D (daughter)Notional partition share (as coparcener) + inheritance1/4 + 1/16 = 5/16
    C (separated son)Inheritance from A as Class I heir only1/16
    TotalCheck16/16

    Note on D: Since D is herself a coparcener at the time of the notional partition, she receives a share equal to that of B in the notional division (i.e., 1/4 of remaining property is notionally allotted to her), and then takes 1/16 of A's share by succession, so her total is 5/16, the same as B's and W's.

    The problem thus presents a finely layered analysis: severance by C, the mechanics of notional partition excluding the separated coparcener, the application of the wider approach from Gurupad v. Hirabai to include the widow's share, and the absolute ownership of the female heirs under Section 14, all operating together to produce a result that is at once logically coherent and remedially just.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.