A & B, two brothers purchased an evacuee property but the sale certificate was issued by the Rehabilitation Authorities in the name of 'A' only. Later on, when some dispute arose between the two brothers regarding partition of the property the matter was referred to a private arbitrator with the consent of both the brothers. The arbitrator gave the Award declaring A & B have equal ownership rights. The Award was also made a rule of the Court by Civil Courts decree. However, A entered into an agreement to sale the entire house in favour of C, who filed a suit for specific performance of the agreement. B got himself impleaded claiming that he was owner of half share in the property. C contested this plea on the ground that B's right in the property was created by the Award which was compulsorily registrable and since the Award was not so registered, B cannot claim any right thereunder. Decide, whether B's claim for half share in the property can be upheld on the basis of unregistered award.
An unregistered private award declaring rights in immovable property is inadmissible alone, but once embodied in a decree the decree binds A and C who claims through him.
B cannot rely on the private award alone to prove his half share, because an award on a private reference that declares rights in immovable property of the value of one hundred rupees or more falls within section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, 1908. B can, however, rely on the decree that made the award a rule of court, and that decree binds A and those who claim through A.
When an award needs registration. An award made on a private reference is a non-testamentary instrument. If it purports or operates to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish a right in immovable property of that value, it must be registered, whether or not anyone seeks to enforce it. The Supreme Court so held in Satish Kumar v Surinder Kumar, AIR 1970 SC 833, and the Andhra Pradesh Full Bench took the same view in Venkataratnam v Chelamayya, AIR 1967 AP 257. The exemption for awards that once appeared in section 17(2)(vi) was removed in 1929, so an award no longer falls within the exemption for decrees and orders. An award that merely gives a right to obtain another document, such as a direction to execute a conveyance, is exempt under section 17(2)(v) (Tehmi P. Sidhwa v Shib Banerjee & Sons Pvt Ltd, (1974) 2 SCC 574).
The award in this case. The arbitrator declared that A and B had equal ownership in the house, although the sale certificate stood in A's name alone. The house was worth far more than Rs 100. The award declares B's right and so operates within section 17(1)(b). It was not registered. Standing alone, it cannot be received to prove B's right, and a court could not have pronounced judgment on it.
The effect of the decree. The award was, however, made a rule of court and a decree was passed. A decree of a court is exempt from registration under section 17(2)(vi), and where an unregistered award has been embodied in a decree that has not been set aside, the award forms part of the decree and binds the parties to the suit. The Lahore High Court so held in Hans Raj v Amar Chand, AIR 1940 Lah 107. A decree on the award is a judgment of the court between A and B. C claims under A through an agreement made after the decree. A purchaser who takes from a party bound by a decree takes subject to it.
Conclusion. B's claim to a half share is sustainable on the strength of the decree, not on the unregistered award. If the decree were set aside, or if the award had not been embodied in a decree, B's claim would fail on the want of registration.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
