'A' bequeaths property worth Rs. 2 Crores to his friend 'B'. A's family members allege that the bequest is invalid for want of registration. Decide the case.
A will bequeathing property worth Rs 2 crores is valid without registration; the objection fails, and only due execution and attestation need be proved.
The bequest by A of property worth Rs 2 crores to his friend B is not invalid for want of registration. A will is outside the documents that the Registration Act, 1908 requires to be registered, whatever the value of the property.
Section 17 does not apply to a will. Section 17(1)(a) covers gifts. Clauses (b), (c) and (e) deal with "non-testamentary" instruments. A will is testamentary, because it speaks from the death of the maker and can be revoked until then. The value of the property does not matter. The Rs 100 threshold in clause (b) concerns non-testamentary instruments, and a will for Rs 2 crores is no more compulsorily registrable than a will for Rs 200.
Registration is a choice. Section 18(e) places a will among the documents that may be registered if the maker wishes, and sections 40 to 46 describe how a will may be presented for registration or deposited with the Registrar in a sealed cover. A will is also the one document that section 23 leaves out of the four-month rule, so it may be registered at any time, and section 27 makes this explicit.
Section 49 has no application. Section 49 applies only to documents required by section 17 or the Transfer of Property Act to be registered. As a will is not one of them, it can affect the property and be received in evidence even if it was never registered.
What the family can challenge. The family members may contest the will on the grounds that it has not been properly executed and proved, that the testator did not have a sound disposing mind, or that there was fraud, undue influence or coercion. The will must satisfy section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925: the testator must sign or affix his mark, the signature must be meant to give effect to the writing as a will, and at least two witnesses must attest it, each having seen the testator sign or received his acknowledgment of the signature. At least one attesting witness must be called to prove it, under the law of evidence now contained in the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. Suspicious circumstances in the making of the will must be explained by the person who relies on it. In certain places, a will also needs probate for the executor to establish his right.
Decision. The objection based on non-registration fails. The bequest to B is valid if the will is proved to have been duly executed and attested.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
