A borrowed a sum of money from B. The last date for filing the suit fell on Sunday. On Monday, the next day A gives a written acknowledgement to B. Advise B whether he should file the suit immediately or he can do so after sometime.
B should file the suit on that Monday, and he should not wait. The acknowledgment does not give him extra time, for the reasons that follow.
The starting point is section 4 of the Act, which provides that "where the prescribed period for any suit, appeal or application expires on a day when the court is closed, the suit, appeal or application may be instituted, preferred or made on the day when the court re-opens". It protects B in one respect only. If the last day for the suit falls on a Sunday, he may file on the Monday and he will be in time. It does not lengthen the period. The period is still the one fixed by the Schedule, and it still expires on the Sunday. All that section 4 does is allow the filing to be made when the court re-opens.
Fixing the dates shows what follows. Suppose A borrowed Rs 50,000 on 11 March 2015. The article for money lent gives three years from the date of the loan, which ends on Sunday, 11 March 2018. The court is closed on that day, and B may therefore file on Monday, 12 March 2018. Suppose A signs a written acknowledgment on that Monday.
Section 18 applies only to an acknowledgment made "before the expiration of the prescribed period". On the reading that the statute bears, the period expired on the Sunday. An acknowledgment signed on the Monday is signed after the period has ended. It does not give a fresh period, and it does not extend the right to file beyond the Monday on which section 4 allows B to institute the suit. The law does not recognise an acknowledgment after the period for the suit has expired as reviving it (Sampuran Singh v Niranjan Kaur, AIR 1999 SC 1047). B cannot say that he is entitled to three more years from the Monday.
There may be an argument that the period should be taken to run until the Monday, so that the acknowledgment falls within it. It would be unwise to depend on it. Section 4 speaks of the suit being "instituted" on the day the court re-opens, not of the period being extended, and an argument that rests on stretching the language of a limitation provision is one that B should not stake his claim on.
There is, however, one thing B can look for in what A has signed. If the writing contains an express promise to pay the debt, wholly or in part, it is a promise "made in writing and signed by the person to be charged" within section 25(3) of the Contract Act, and it can be enforced even though the debt is time-barred. B could then sue on the promise itself. Such a promise is a fresh contract with its own period of limitation. The point to note is that this is a different cause of action and not a continuation of the original one, and an acknowledgment that merely admits the debt without promising to pay will not do.
B's advice is therefore plain. He should file the suit on the Monday itself, the day the court re-opens, on the original cause of action, and he can plead the promise in the alternative if A's writing contains one. A filing on the Tuesday or later would be out of time, and the acknowledgment could not save it unless it can stand as a section 25(3) promise.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
