'A' deposits the title deeds of his property with 'B' to secure payment of a loan made to him by 'B'. A then executes a legal mortgage of the same property to 'C'. The mortgage deed to C is duly registered. Is 'C' entitled to priority over 'B'. Decide with the help of relevant provisions of the Registration Act.
A mortgage by deposit of title deeds takes effect against a later executed and registered mortgage deed on the same property under the proviso to section 48.
A deposits title deeds with B to secure a loan, and then executes a registered legal mortgage of the same property to C. B has priority over C. The Registration Act, 1908 states this expressly in the proviso to section 48.
The nature of B's mortgage. A mortgage by deposit of title deeds, defined in section 58(f) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, is made when a person in certain towns delivers to a creditor, or his agent, documents of title to immovable property with the intent to create a security. It needs no written instrument and, therefore, no registration. If the parties make a memorandum that only records the deposit, it need not be registered; if the memorandum creates rights and liabilities itself, it must be (State of Haryana v Narvir Singh, (2014) 1 SCC 105).
The general rule of priority. Under section 47, a registered document operates from the time it would have begun to operate if registration had not been required, not from the time of its registration. Under section 50(1), a registered document of the kinds in section 17(1)(a) to (d) takes effect against an unregistered document concerning the same property. C's mortgage deed is registered, and so, on the general rule, C would prevail over an unregistered document.
The proviso to section 48. Section 48 provides that registered non-testamentary documents take effect against oral agreements. The proviso adds that a mortgage by deposit of title deeds, as defined in section 58 of the Transfer of Property Act, takes effect against any mortgage deed subsequently executed and registered which relates to the same property. B's deposit was earlier, and C's mortgage deed was executed later. The proviso applies directly, and B's mortgage takes priority over C's, although B has no registered instrument.
Reason. A deposit of title deeds is a transaction completed by delivery. The law recognises it without a document, so it cannot be made to depend on registration. The person who later takes a legal mortgage can protect himself by asking for the title deeds. If he does not have them, he is put on enquiry.
Conclusion. C is not entitled to priority over B. B's equitable mortgage prevails against C's later registered mortgage deed under the proviso to section 48. C can still enforce his own mortgage against the property subject to B's prior claim, and against A personally.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
