A directs in his will that income from his property be accumulated for 25 years and then distributed among his grandchildren. Discuss validity.
Answer:
Validity of Testamentary Direction for 25-Year Accumulation
The testamentary direction by A requires careful analysis under section 117 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, which governs a direction for accumulation in a Will (a Will is not a "transfer" within the Transfer of Property Act, so section 17 of that Act is only the parallel provision for transfers inter vivos). The validity of the 25-year accumulation period depends on applying the statutory temporal limits and determining whether any exception applies.
Application of Section 117 of the Indian Succession Act: The Temporal Limit
The Statutory Framework
Section 117 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides that where the terms of a Will direct that income arising from property shall be accumulated, wholly or in part, during a period longer than eighteen years from the death of the testator, the direction is void to the extent to which it exceeds that period, and at the end of the eighteen years the property and the income are disposed of as if the period of accumulation had elapsed. Section 17 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is the parallel provision for transfers inter vivos: it avoids a direction to accumulate beyond the longer of the transferor's life and eighteen years from the date of the transfer.
Time from which the Eighteen Years Run
Under section 117 the period is counted from the death of the testator, when the Will takes effect, and not from the date on which the Will was executed. A will is ambulatory and creates no interest in property until the testator's death.
Therefore, the eighteen-year period begins to run from A's death, not from the date A executed the will.
Why the Alternative Periods in Section 17 Do Not Arise
Section 117 gives no choice between the life of the testator and eighteen years: the only period is eighteen years from the testator's death. (Under section 17 of the Transfer of Property Act the longer of the transferor's life and eighteen years from the transfer applies; for a Will the testator's life has ended by the time it operates, so the result is the same: eighteen years from A's death.)
Application to the 25-Year Direction
A has directed accumulation for 25 years from the date of his death (the effective date of the testamentary transfer). This exceeds the longer permissible period of eighteen years by seven years.
Consequence: Under section 117, the direction for accumulation is valid for eighteen years from A's death and void for the remaining seven years.
Section 117 makes the direction void to the extent that the period of accumulation exceeds eighteen years from the testator's death. This contemplates partial invalidity—the direction remains operative during the lawful eighteen-year period and fails only as to the excess seven years.
Effect After the Eighteen-Year Period
Statutory Disposition
At the end of eighteen years from A's death, section 117 (like section 17(1) of the Transfer of Property Act) mandates that "the property and the income thereof shall be disposed of as if the period during which the accumulation has been directed to be made had elapsed".
This means:
Accumulation ceases at the end of the eighteenth year;
Distribution to grandchildren commences at that point, not after 25 years as A directed; and
Income arising after year eighteen must be distributed currently rather than accumulated.
The accumulated income from years one through eighteen, together with the corpus, becomes distributable among the grandchildren who are then in existence and entitled under the will's terms.
Intermediate Income
Any income arising during years nineteen through twenty-five cannot be accumulated as A directed. Instead, it must be distributed to the grandchildren entitled under the will as it arises, following the beneficial interests A created (subject to the failed accumulation direction).
Could the Portions Exception Apply?
Section 117, Exception (ii): Provision of Portions (parallel to section 17(2)(ii) of the Transfer of Property Act)
The exceptions in section 117, which correspond to section 17(2) of the Transfer of Property Act, provide that the general limit "shall not affect any direction for accumulation for the purpose of...the provision of portions for children or remoter issue of the transferor or of any other person taking any interest under the transfer".
A "portion" means a share in property settled in favour of children or their issues. Grandchildren constitute "remoter issue" of the transferor.
Analysis of A's Direction
A has directed accumulation for ultimate distribution among his grandchildren. This appears facially to fall within the portions exception, which permits accumulation "for the purpose of the provision of portions for...remoter issue of the transferor".
If the portions exception applies, the accumulation may continue beyond the eighteen-year period, as accumulation for portions "may exceed the prescribed period" (see Edwards v. Tuck).
Requirements for the Portions Exception
However, the portions exception has been construed to require that accumulation serve the specific purpose of raising portions—creating separate provision for children or issue—rather than merely augmenting what they would receive in any event.
The exception "does not apply to the making of additions of income to capital in order to increase the capital for the person to whom it is given" (see Vine v. Raleigh, 1891 2 Ch 13). The distinction is between:
Accumulation to create portions: Income is accumulated to build up separate funds for children/issue who might not otherwise receive adequate provision; or
Accumulation merely to augment: Income is accumulated simply to increase the quantum of what beneficiaries will eventually receive.
Application to A's Direction
The facts state that A directs accumulation "and then distributed among his grandchildren." This formulation suggests that:
The grandchildren are the ultimate beneficiaries of both corpus and accumulated income;
The accumulation serves to augment what they will receive; and
No separate "portions" distinct from their general beneficial entitlement are being created.
Conclusion on Exception: Unless the will contains further provisions indicating that the accumulation serves to create separate portions for grandchildren who might not otherwise be adequately provided for (as distinct from merely increasing the size of their inheritance), the portions exception likely does not apply.
If the will shows that A intended to create specific portions—for instance, equal shares for each grandchild to be raised by accumulation, where some grandchildren might otherwise receive nothing or inadequate amounts—the exception might be engaged. However, on the facts as stated, the direction appears to be a general accumulation to augment the ultimate distribution rather than a provision of portions in the technical sense.
Issues Relating to Grandchildren as Beneficiaries
Unborn Grandchildren and Section 13
An additional issue arises if some of A's grandchildren are not yet born at the time of A's death. Section 113 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (the testamentary counterpart of section 13 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882) restricts bequests to persons not in existence at the testator's death, permitting them only where:
A prior bequest is made in favour of a person living at the testator's death; and
The bequest to the unborn person comprises the whole of the remaining interest of the testator in the thing bequeathed.
If A's grandchildren include both those living at his death and those yet to be born, the gift would typically be structured to satisfy section 113 of the Indian Succession Act (and, for a transfer inter vivos, section 13 of the Transfer of Property Act)—for example, by creating a life interest in favour of A's children with remainder to grandchildren. The accumulation direction might then serve to build up the fund during the lives of A's children for ultimate distribution to grandchildren.
This structure might strengthen the argument for the portions exception, as the accumulation would serve to create adequate portions for a class of remoter issue, some of whom are unborn.
Distribution Among Grandchildren
The direction to distribute "among his grandchildren" raises questions of:
Which grandchildren are included: Only those living at A's death? Those living at the end of the accumulation period? All who come into existence before distribution?
How distribution is effected: Per capita (equally among all grandchildren)? Per stirpes (by family branch)? According to some other formula?
These questions affect the operation of the accumulation but do not directly bear on its validity under section 17.
Practical Outcome and Current Legal Position
Most Likely Result
Absent special circumstances engaging the portions exception, the direction for 25-year accumulation is valid for eighteen years from A's death and void for the remaining seven years.
During years 1-18: Income from A's property is accumulated as directed.
At the end of year 18: The accumulated income and corpus are distributed among A's grandchildren then entitled, as if the directed accumulation period had elapsed.
During years 19-25: If any income continues to arise and no distribution is yet possible (e.g., because of ongoing administration), that income cannot be further accumulated but must be held for current distribution or distributed as it arises to the entitled grandchildren.
If the Portions Exception Applies
If the will's terms demonstrate that the accumulation genuinely serves to provide portions for grandchildren in the technical sense, the full 25-year accumulation period would be valid, as "accumulation in such cases may exceed the prescribed period".
However, the burden rests on those asserting the exception to demonstrate that it applies. Courts construe exceptions to the rule against accumulation strictly, as the rule embodies important policy against dead-hand control and unproductive tying up of wealth.
Reformulation to Achieve Validity
If A's Intention Was to Benefit Grandchildren Fully
If A's true intention was to maximize the fund ultimately passing to grandchildren, and if A is still alive and can revise the will, the following approaches might be considered:
Option 1: Limit the accumulation period to eighteen years from death, achieving partial implementation of A's objective within statutory limits.
Option 2: Structure the gift as a provision of portions, making clear that separate funds are being created for individual grandchildren or family branches, potentially engaging the exception.
Option 3: Frame the accumulation as serving preservation and maintenance of the property under the corresponding exception in section 117 (section 17(2)(iii) of the Transfer of Property Act), though this would require that the property genuinely require such provision.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
