Registration ActGift and Family Settlement 07 July 2026· 4 min read

    A executed a gift deed in favour of his nephew (sister's son) in respect of some agricultural land. His brothers B, C & D filed a suit challenging the gift made by A to his nephew on the ground that all the four brothers were members of a coparcenery and A could not make a gift of coparcenary property without the consent of other coparceners. In defence, A pleaded that a mutual partition had already taken place in July 1952 and the property in question had fallen to his share so he could validly gift it to his nephew. He relied on a list Ex. D, of the coparcenary properties which were mutually divided. The execution of Ex. D, was admitted by the plaintiffs but they contended that Ex. D amounted to a partition deed which required compulsory registration under section 17 of Registration Act. Can Ex. D, be taken into consideration for ascertaining the intention and conduct of the parties as to the disruption of coparcenary? Decide giving reasons.

    An unregistered partition list can be used to show severance of joint status but not as the operative document allotting specific land.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Ex. D can be looked at to find whether the brothers had separated, but it cannot be used as the document by which specific properties were allotted to A. The two uses are different, and the Registration Act, 1908 treats them differently.

    What a partition is. A partition of joint family property has two parts. One is the severance of the joint status, which depends on the intention of a member to separate and can be shown by conduct, a notice or a declaration. The other is the division of the property by metes and bounds. A document that creates, declares or extinguishes a right in immovable property of the value of one hundred rupees or more has to be registered under section 17(1)(b). A list that records a division already made, and does not itself operate to divide, is not within that clause.

    Effect of non-registration. If Ex. D is a document of partition that operates to divide the lands, it required registration. Under section 49, it then could not affect the property it comprises or be received as evidence of the division. The proviso permits an unregistered document to be received only for a collateral purpose, and a document of partition, even if unregistered, can be used to prove a fact that does not depend on its operative force. The Supreme Court has held that an unregistered partition deed may be received to show the severance of joint status, which does not need the document to be effective as a partition (Thulasidhara v Narayanappa, Supreme Court, 2019).

    Application. A pleaded that a mutual partition took place in July 1952 and that the property fell to his share. The plaintiffs admitted the execution of Ex. D, but said it was a partition deed requiring registration. If that is right, A cannot use Ex. D to prove that the land was allotted to him. He can, however, use it to prove that the coparcenary was disrupted: the list, which is admittedly executed, shows that the brothers treated their properties as divided, and the intention and conduct of the parties as to separation is a matter on which other evidence, such as separate enjoyment and mutation, can also be led. If the joint family had ended, A had no coparceners whose consent was needed for the gift, and the question of the extent of his share could be proved by oral evidence of the separate possession that followed.

    Family settlement. Where the partition is part of a family arrangement made to settle disputes, courts take a liberal view, and recognise a family settlement that is acted upon, since it avoids litigation within the family (Kale v Deputy Director of Consolidation, (1976) 3 SCC 119). Where parties have acted on the division, a memorandum made afterwards to record what was done is not itself the instrument of partition and need not be registered.

    Conclusion. Ex. D can be considered for the purpose of ascertaining the intention and conduct of the parties as to the disruption of the coparcenary. It cannot be used as the operative document dividing the land.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.