Contract ActDischarge of Contract 13 May 2026· 4 min read

    A, female singer agreed to sing in B's theatre. Day before programme, she took ice-cream, voice cracked, unable to sing. B sues for damages. Can B succeed?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The general principle in contract law, as implied by the context of performance, is that parties to a contract must either perform or offer to perform their respective promises unless performance is dispensed with or excused.

    In this case, the singer (A) contracted with the theatre manager (B) for a personal service – singing at the theatre. This type of contract relies on the specific individual and their ability to perform.

    The scenario where the singer's voice cracks due to eating ice cream, rendering her unable to sing, falls under the category of performance becoming impossible due to a supervening event [Section 56, 40, 167]. While the act of eating ice cream might be seen as related to the cause, the crucial legal point is the resulting inability to perform, which makes the performance impossible at the scheduled time.

    Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, deals with agreements to do impossible acts. It states that "A contract to do an act which, after the contract is made, becomes impossible, or, by reason of some event which the promisor could not prevent, unlawful, becomes void when the act becomes impossible or unlawful". This is known as the doctrine of frustration. The essential idea is the impossibility of performance due to changed circumstances.

    The illustrations directly relevant to a singer's inability to perform:

    • Illustration (e) to Section 56 states: "A contracts to act at a theatre for six months in consideration of a sum paid in advance by B. On several occasions A is too ill to act. The contract to act on those occasions becomes void". A cracked voice leading to inability to sing is akin to being "too ill to act."

    • Similarly, Illustration (d) to Section 65 (dealing with obligations when a contract becomes void) involves a singer who is too ill to sing at a concert for which she was paid in advance.

    A relevant caselaw is Robinson v. Davison, where a piano player was contracted to perform at a concert but could not attend due to illness. The court held that the defendant (piano player) was not liable, as performance was impossible due to illness. The contract was considered subject to the condition of her being well enough to perform, and if that foundation fails, the contract fails. Poussard v Spiers (1876) 1 QBD 410, is a case where an actress's illness before the opening performances was held to go to the root of the contract.

    Applying these principles to the scenario:

    • The contract is for a personal service where the singer's physical ability is essential.

    • The singer becoming unable to perform due to a cracked voice, even if caused by eating ice cream, results in the performance becoming impossible at the contracted time.

    • Under Section 56, the contract for that specific performance (the program night) becomes void due to impossibility.

    Consequences for the parties:

    1. Rights of the Theatre Manager (B):

      • Since the contract becomes void due to impossibility under Section 56, B is not entitled to sue A for damages for breach of contract in the same way he could if A had willfully refused to perform (which would be a breach under Section 39, allowing rescission and damages under Section 75). Impossibility excuses performance.

      • However, if B had paid A any advance for the night A was unable to sing, A would have an obligation to refund the advance payment under the principle of Section 65. Section 65 states that when a contract becomes void, any person who has received any advantage under the agreement is bound to restore it or make compensation for it. Illustration (d) confirms this obligation for a singer paid in advance who falls ill.

    2. Rights of the Singer (A):

      • A is excused from performing on the night she is unable to sing due to the voice issue, as the contract for that performance becomes void due to impossibility [Section 56, 40, 47, 85, 167].

      • A is not liable to compensate B for losses such as lost profits, as the non-performance is due to impossibility recognized by law, not a willful breach.

      • If A received payment for the specific performance that became impossible, A has an obligation to refund that payment to B [Section 65, 36, 42, 91].

    In conclusion, B's suit for damages for breach of contract is unlikely to succeed because the contract for the performance is discharged by frustration/impossibility under Section 56, not breached by a refusal to perform. B may, however, be entitled to a refund of any money paid to A for the performance that did not take place [Section 65, 36, 42, 91].

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.