Contract ActFree Consent 12 May 2026· 4 min read

    A filed suit against maternal uncle B for partition. B resisted on ground that A's mother (blind, tribal woman) executed sale deed in B's favor. A challenges on undue influence. Decide onus of proof

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    In the scenario, where A challenges a sale deed executed by his mother (a blind, tribal woman) in favour of his maternal uncle (B) on the ground of undue influence, the question of who bears the burden of proof is crucial.

    1. General Rule for Burden of Proof: Ordinarily, the party alleging undue influence (in this case, A, challenging the deed on behalf of his mother or affecting his rights) bears the burden of proving that their consent (or his mother's consent) was not free. They must show that the other party (B) was in a position to dominate their will and actually used that position to obtain consent to the contract.

    2. Undue Influence and Dominant Position: Undue influence occurs when the relations between the parties are such that one is in a position to dominate the will of the other and uses that position to gain an unfair advantage. A person is deemed to be in a position to dominate the will of another where they hold real or apparent authority, or stand in a fiduciary relation, or where the parties are not on equal footing.

    3. Shifting of Burden under Section 16(3): The law provides for a shift in the burden of proof in certain circumstances. According to Section 16(3) of the Contract Act, when a person who is in a position to dominate the will of another enters into a contract with them, and the transaction appears unconscionable (unfair) on the face of it or based on evidence, the burden of proving that the contract was not induced by undue influence shifts to the person in a position to dominate the will of the other. Section 16(3) is a rule of evidence. (The related presumption of active confidence, formerly Section 111 of the Evidence Act, 1872, is now in the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, Section 120.)

    4. Relationships and Vulnerability: While mere near relationship by blood, marriage, or adoption does not automatically create a presumption of undue influence, certain relationships and circumstances can establish that one party is in a position to dominate the other's will, especially where there is active trust and confidence, or the parties are not on equal footing. Recognized special relationships where a presumption can arise include parent and child (though the illustration refers to a father's influence over a son who has come of age, not necessarily a vulnerable parent), but the key is the ability to dominate the will.

    5. Specific Case of Vulnerability: The courts are particularly vigilant when one party is in a vulnerable position. For instance, a presumption of undue influence arises in the case of a contract by or with a pardanasheen woman (living in seclusion), where the party contracting with her must prove she understood the document. More directly relevant to the present scenario is the discussion of the case Sethani v Bhana (AIR 1993 SC 956). In that case, the sale deed was by a tribal woman, who was old, illiterate and blind. The court considered these factors, along with the absence of apparent consideration and the woman living with and being dependent on the purchaser. It was held that the purchaser carried the burden of proving that the sale deed was not executed under undue influence. This suggests that the combined vulnerabilities (tribal status, blindness, and potentially illiteracy and dependence, although only blindness and tribal status are explicitly mentioned for A's mother) are sufficient grounds for the court to presume the possibility of undue influence.

    6. Applying to the Scenario: In the present case, A's mother is described as a blind, tribal woman. This description aligns closely with the characteristics of the vulnerable party in Sethani v Bhana, which held that these factors shift the burden of proof to the dominant party. While B is her brother (maternal uncle to A), the relationship itself isn't the sole factor; it's the combination of the relationship and the mother's significant vulnerability (blindness and tribal status) that likely establishes that B was in a position to dominate her will, or at least that the parties were not on equal footing. Given these circumstances and the nature of the transaction (sale of property), a court would likely find that the presumption of undue influence arises under Section 16(3).

    Therefore, in this case, the onus of proving that the sale deed was not induced by undue influence will likely lie upon B (the maternal uncle). A would need to present evidence showing his mother's vulnerability (blindness, tribal status, possibly dependence or illiteracy if applicable) to establish that B was in a position to dominate her will. Once that is shown, and potentially if the transaction appears unconscionable, the burden shifts to B to demonstrate that his sister's consent to the sale deed was free and independent. This might involve showing she had independent advice, fully understood the transaction, and received adequate consideration, among other factors, to rebut the presumption. Independently of undue influence, a sale of land by a tribal woman in a Scheduled Area may also be void under the applicable land-transfer restrictions (for example, the Andhra Pradesh Scheduled Areas Land Transfer Regulation, 1959).

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.