A Hindu male died in 1987 leaving son, daughter, father, grandson's widow. Divide his property.
Identifying the Heirs and Their Categories
The intestate, a Hindu male, died in 1987. The question does not say what kind of property he left, so it is assumed to be his separate property. The survivors are:
Son (S), Class I heir
Daughter (D), Class I heir
Father (F), Class II heir (Entry I)
Grandson's widow (GsW), whether she is an heir depends on how the problem is read
As the death occurred in 1987, the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 does not apply and the original Act governs.
Is the Grandson's Widow an Heir?
The "grandson's widow" is taken to be the widow of the intestate's son's son. The Class I heirs in the Schedule include the widow of a predeceased son and the widow of a predeceased son of a predeceased son. A grandson's widow is therefore a Class I heir only if both the son and the grandson through whom she is related died before the intestate.
In addition, the original Section 24, which was in force in 1987, disqualified such a widow if she had remarried before the succession opened. The date for this purpose is the date of the intestate's death.
The Father's Position, A Critical Exclusion
The father of a male intestate is not a Class I heir. He is the first entry in Class II. Under Section 9, a Class II heir takes only if there is no Class I heir. Here the son and the daughter are Class I heirs, so the father takes nothing.
The father's place in Class II, while the mother is in Class I, is criticised by some as anomalous, but it is the law under the Schedule.
Computing the Shares
We now apply Section 10:
Each son and daughter takes one share (Rule 2)
The intestate left no widow, so Rule 1 does not apply
The grandson's widow can take only as the widow of a predeceased son of a predeceased son, and then only if the branch of the predeceased son has no other member
She is an heir only if her husband's father, a son of the intestate, also predeceased the intestate. If that son is alive, there is no predeceased son's branch through which she can claim, and she is not an heir.
The problem states that the son is alive. On that reading, the widow's husband was a son of the living son and died before the intestate. She is the widow of a son of a living son, and the Schedule does not make her an heir.
The answer below follows this reading, which is the natural one. The grandson's widow takes nothing. An alternative reading is mentioned at the end.
Distribution
Reading adopted (the son is alive and only the grandson predeceased):
| Heir | Share |
|---|---|
| Son (S) | 1/2 |
| Daughter (D) | 1/2 |
| Father (F) | Nil (excluded by Class I heirs) |
| Grandson's widow (GsW) | Nil (not a Class I heir in these facts) |
The property divides equally between the son and daughter, with the father and the grandson's widow both excluded.
Alternative reading (the grandson's widow is the widow of a son of a predeceased son, and the surviving son is another son of the intestate):
Under Rule 3 of Section 10 the branch of the predeceased son takes one share, and as the widow is its only member she takes that share. The living son and the daughter take one share each.
| Heir | Share |
|---|---|
| Living Son | 1/3 |
| Daughter | 1/3 |
| Grandson's widow (branch of predeceased son) | 1/3 |
| Father | Nil |
The Governing Principle
On either reading the father is excluded, because one Class I heir is enough to exclude him under Section 9. The reading is not an anomaly of the Act: it follows the Schedule, which places the intestate's descendants and the mother in Class I and the father in Class II.
The grandson's widow, if she had not remarried before the succession opened, inherits as a Class I heir only when both the son and the grandson predeceased the intestate. If the property was coparcenary.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
