A Hindu male died intestate leaving adopted son, illegitimate son, married daughter, mother and father. Property distribution.
The Survivors: Classification at a Glance
The survivors are an adopted son, an illegitimate son, a married daughter, a mother and a father. The outcome depends on where each stands in the Schedule. The property is assumed to be the intestate's separate property.
The adopted son stands on the same footing as a natural-born son. The Schedule lists "son" as a Class I heir, and under Section 3(1)(c) of the Act relationship by adoption is relationship by blood. Under Section 12 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 an adopted child is deemed to be the child of the adoptive father for all purposes from the date of adoption. He is therefore a Class I heir.
The Illegitimate Son: A Critical Exclusion
Section 3(1)(j) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 provides that "related" means related by legitimate kinship, with the proviso that illegitimate children are deemed to be related to their mother and to one another, and their legitimate descendants to them. An illegitimate son is therefore not related to his father in law and is not a "son" for the purpose of inheriting from him. He cannot succeed to the father's property as a Class I heir or as any other heir. He may claim maintenance out of the father's estate as a dependant under Section 21(viii) read with Section 22 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, so long as he is a minor. This is a result of the definition of "related" and not a disqualification.The result would differ if his parents' marriage was void or voidable. Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 treats the child of such a marriage as legitimate, and in Revanasiddappa v. Mallikarjun ((2011) 11 SCC 1) the Supreme Court held that such a child is entitled to a share in his parents' property. A son born outside any marriage stands differently. The problem does not give the facts, so the answer below takes him to be a son born outside marriage.
The Married Daughter: Full Equality
The married daughter is a Class I heir. The Schedule lists "daughter" without qualification, and her marriage does not affect her right to succeed. She inherits equally with the other Class I heirs.
The Mother: Class I; The Father: Class II
The mother is expressly listed in Class I of the Schedule. She inherits simultaneously with the other Class I heirs and takes an equal share. The father is the first heir in Class II, Entry I. Under Section 9, a Class II heir takes only if there is no Class I heir, so the father is excluded. In the present problem, three Class I heirs are alive, the adopted son, the married daughter, and the mother, and therefore the father takes nothing.
The Act does not place the father in Class I, and he stands behind even distant Class I heirs. Some commentators regard this as anomalous, but it is the law.
The Distribution of Property
With the father excluded and the illegitimate son ineligible, the property devolves among three Class I heirs: the adopted son, the married daughter, and the mother. Under Section 10, Rule 2, each of them takes one share, so the property is divided into three equal parts.
| Heir | Class | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Adopted Son | Class I | 1/3 |
| Married Daughter | Class I | 1/3 |
| Mother | Class I | 1/3 |
| Father | Class II | Nil (excluded by Class I heirs) |
| Illegitimate Son | Not an heir of the father | Nil (maintenance as a dependant while a minor) |
The estate is therefore divided equally among the adopted son, the married daughter and the mother.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
