Contract ActDischarge of Contract 13 May 2026· 4 min read

    A in Delhi contracts with B in Mumbai to supply jute material "as supplied by Jute Mills Calcutta". Mills shut down due to losses. B sues for damages. Decide

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The fundamental principle of contract law is that parties are obliged to perform or offer to perform their respective promises, unless performance is dispensed with or excused [Section 37]. In this case, A promised to supply jute material to B.

    The issue that arises is whether the closure of the specific jute mills named in the contract excuses A's performance under the doctrine of frustration, or if it constitutes a breach of contract. The doctrine of frustration is covered by Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, which states that an agreement to do an act which, after the contract is made, becomes impossible, becomes void when the act becomes impossible.

    However, case laws like Harnandarai Fulchand v Pragdas and Ganga Saran v Ram Charan Ram Gopal dealt with contracts where goods were to be supplied from specified mills, and those mills failed to perform.

    In Harnandarai Fulchand v Pragdas, where dhotis were to be manufactured by specified mills and delivered as received from those mills, and the mills failed to perform, it was held that it was a simple case of breach, and the bargain was not frustrated. The court indicated that the stipulation as to delivery did not make delivery by the mills a condition precedent.

    Similarly, in Ganga Saran v Ram Charan Ram Gopal, a contract for supplying cloth manufactured by the New Victoria Mills, Kanpur, with a clause stating "We shall go on supplying goods to you of the Victoria Mills as soon as they are supplied to us by the said mills," was held to be a simple case of breach when the mill failed to supply. The Supreme Court applied the principle that the contract was not frustrated.

    Applying the principle derived from these cases to the present scenario, the phrase "as supplied by Jute Mills Calcutta" is likely to be interpreted as describing the type, quality, or origin of the jute material, rather than making the continued operation and supply from those specific mills an absolute condition precedent for A's obligation to supply the jute material. Unless the contract explicitly made performance absolutely dependent on the specific, irreplaceable supply from those particular mills in a way that was the known foundation of the entire agreement (which is not explicitly stated in the present scenario and generally disfavoured by courts in commercial contracts), the closure of the mills does not render the contract frustrated under Section 56.

    Instead, A's inability to supply the jute material as agreed due to the closure of the specified mills constitutes a breach of contract.

    When a contract has been broken by one party, the other party who suffers by such breach is entitled to receive compensation for any loss or damage caused to him thereby [Section 73]. This compensation is for loss or damage that naturally arose in the usual course of things from such breach, or which the parties knew, when they made the contract, to be likely to result from the breach of it [Section 73]. Damages awarded are generally compensatory, aiming to put the suffering party in the same position as if the contract had been performed.

    In a contract for the sale of goods like jute material, where the seller breaches the contract by failing to deliver, the general measure of damages is the difference between the contract price and the market price of the goods on the date of the breach [Section 73, Illustration (a)]. The buyer is entitled to receive the sum, if any, by which the contract price falls short of the market price [Section 73, Illustration (a)].

    The buyer (B) also has a duty to mitigate the loss resulting from the breach [Explanation to Section 73]. This means B should take reasonable steps to minimize the damages, such as attempting to purchase similar jute material from another source. However, as held in Jamal v Moola Dawood Sons & Co., the measure of damages is fixed at the date of the breach based on the market price then, and any subsequent fluctuations in price or the seller's actions in reselling the goods later do not alter the damages due. The market rate theory is a key principle for assessing damages in contracts for sale or purchase of goods.

    Therefore, B can succeed in suing A for damages for breach of contract [Section 73]. The amount of damages B is entitled to recover would generally be the difference between the contract price of the jute material and the market price of similar material in Mumbai (or the agreed place of delivery) on the date A failed to perform, plus any incidental expenses that naturally arose from the breach [Section 73, Illustration (a)]. The fact that A's specific source of supply failed is treated as A's problem, not an event frustrating the contract itself, unless the contract's terms clearly indicated otherwise.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.