A industrial fell into bad times, couldn't pay Municipal tax of Rs. 2 lakhs on Cotton Mill. Leased mill to B. B paid taxes to save property from sale. Can B recover from A?
B, the lessee, can recover the municipal tax amount from A, the lessor. This is based on the principles found in the Indian Contract Act, 1872, specifically relating to the reimbursement of a person paying money due by another, in payment of which he is interested.
Relevant Provision: Section 69 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872:
Section 69 reads: "A person who is interested in the payment of money, which another is bound by law to pay, and who therefore, pays it, is entitled to be reimbursed by the other."
Application to the Scenario:
In the present scenario, A was legally bound by law to pay the municipal tax on the Cotton Mill. The failure to pay led to the property being advertised for sale [implied from the scenario].
B is the lessee of the mill. B has an interest in the payment of the money (the municipal tax) because the sale of the property for arrears of tax would likely affect B's lease or possession of the mill [implied from the scenario, and directly mirrored in the illustration provided under Section 69 about a lessee paying arrears to prevent sale and annulment of lease].
B paid the tax to the Municipality (another party), which was legally due by A, to prevent the sale of the property [implied from the scenario].
The law imposes an obligation on A to reimburse B for the payment.
Explanation and Caselaw:
The requirements for Section 69 to apply are: (i) The plaintiff (B) must be interested in the payment of the money. (ii) The defendant (A) must be bound by law to pay. The phrase "bound by law" means bound by law or by contract, and it is enough that the defendant might be compelled to pay at the suit of any person. A, as the owner, was bound to pay the municipal tax. (iii) The plaintiff should have made the payment to another person and not to himself. B paid the municipality.
This section is an application of the principle that a person who is compelled to pay money which another is legally bound to pay, and in which the former is interested, is entitled to recover it [implied from the context of Section 69].
A relevant caselaw that illustrates this principle is Govindram Gordhandas v State (AIR 1950 PC 99), also cited as Govindram Gordhandas Seksaria v State of Gondal. In this case, where a Maharaja sold certain mills without paying overdue municipal taxes, the buyer had to pay the taxes to save the property from being sold in execution. The buyer was allowed to recover the amount paid from the seller (the Maharaja) under Section 69. This case demonstrates that the person who was legally obligated to pay the tax is liable to reimburse the person who paid it to protect their interest in the property.
Therefore, applying Section 69 of the Indian Contract Act and the principle upheld in cases like Govindram Gordhandas v State, B is entitled to be reimbursed by A for the Rs. 2 lakhs in municipal tax paid to save the Cotton Mill from sale.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
