Constitutional LawServices under the Union and the States 06 August 2026· 6 min read

    A is Constable in the India Police Force. On receipt of information an enquiry is held by his superior officer Y, into charges of corruption and dishonesty against him and intimately, X is case if oral disposal to a Tribunal specially proposed to deal with such cases. Please draft your advice.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Opinion.

    The question is not clear on one point. It is taken here that an inquiry into charges of corruption and dishonesty against the constable has been held by his superior officer Y, and that the case is to be disposed of by a Tribunal specially constituted to deal with such cases. The advice is given on that footing. If the facts differ, the advice on the last two heads may change.

    1. A is protected by Article 311. A constable in a State police force is a civil servant who holds office during the pleasure of the Governor [Article 310]. That pleasure is not unlimited. Article 311 is an express provision of the Constitution, and rules and laws made under Article 309 are subject to it [UOI v Tulsiram Patel, AIR 1985 SC 1416 : (1985) 3 SCC 398]. Dismissal, removal or reduction in rank are major penalties, and these attract Article 311. A constable was once discharged without a hearing after an order that cast a stigma on him, and the Supreme Court held that he should have been given a reasonable opportunity.

    2. The authority to dismiss. Under Article 311(1) A cannot be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to the one that appointed him. This does not require that the appointing authority itself conduct the inquiry. It is enough that the dismissing authority is not subordinate in rank to the appointing authority. The inquiry may be conducted by Y even though Y is a subordinate officer, since a superior authority may entrust the inquiry to a subordinate and act on the report. In State of Madhya Pradesh v Shardul Singh, (1970) 1 SCC 108, a sub-inspector was dismissed by the Inspector General after an inquiry conducted by the Superintendent of Police, and the dismissal was upheld, because Article 311(1) guarantees only that the dismissing authority is not subordinate to the appointing authority. So the question to examine is who appointed A and who will pass the order of dismissal.

    3. The inquiry must satisfy Article 311(2). Before any major penalty can be imposed, A must be told the charges against him and given a reasonable opportunity of being heard. The following points should be examined in Y's inquiry: - The charges must be clear and precise. A vague charge that he accepts bribes is not enough, and particulars of specific acts must be given. - A must be informed of the evidence on which the charges rest, and given copies of the relevant documents. If the non-supply of documents has prejudiced him, the inquiry is vitiated. - He must be allowed to cross-examine the witnesses against him and to lead his defence. A synopsis of the witnesses' earlier statements will not suffice. If witnesses were examined in his absence at a preliminary inquiry, copies of those statements should be given to him. - The findings must rest on some evidence. Private inquiries made behind his back, or findings based on secret information not disclosed to him, will vitiate the inquiry. The strict rules of the Evidence Act do not apply. - A personal hearing, if demanded, cannot be refused. - After the inquiry officer finds the charges proved, A is entitled to a copy of the inquiry report and to comment on it before the disciplinary authority decides [UOI v Mohd Ramzan Khan, AIR 1991 SC 471; Managing Director, ECIL v B Karunakar, AIR 1994 SC 1074]. A second notice on the proposed penalty is no longer needed, because the Forty-second Amendment abolished it. But failure to supply the report invalidates the order only if A shows prejudice. - If the disciplinary authority disagrees with a finding of the inquiry officer that the charges are not proved, it must record its tentative reasons and give A a chance to respond [Punjab National Bank v Kunj Behari Misra, AIR 1998 SC 2713].

    4. The inquiry may be dispensed with only in three cases. Under the second proviso to Article 311(2), no inquiry is needed if A is dismissed on conduct that led to his conviction on a criminal charge, if the authority records in writing that it is not reasonably practicable to hold an inquiry, or if the President or Governor is satisfied that, in the interest of the security of the State, an inquiry is not expedient. None of these appears on the facts given, since an inquiry has in fact been held and no conviction or security ground is mentioned. The reasons for dispensing with an inquiry under clause (b) must be recorded, and must be germane to the issue.

    5. Parallel criminal proceedings. Since the charge is corruption, a criminal prosecution may be started. The departmental inquiry and the prosecution may go on at the same time, since the standard of proof is different (preponderance of probabilities against proof beyond reasonable doubt), and an acquittal does not by itself end the departmental proceedings [Nelson Motis v UOI, AIR 1992 SC 1981]. In the case of a grave charge on identical facts and evidence, involving complicated questions of law and fact, it is desirable to stay the departmental proceedings until the criminal case ends [Anthony]. A may consider seeking a stay on that ground if the prosecution rests on the same evidence. This will depend on the facts.

    6. The Tribunal. Under Article 323A, Parliament may set up tribunals to adjudicate disputes about the recruitment and conditions of service of public servants, which includes the dismissal of government servants, and may exclude the jurisdiction of all courts except the Supreme Court under Article 136. The Central Administrative Tribunal exercises a jurisdiction like that of the High Court under Article 226. It is supervisory in nature, so it cannot reappreciate the evidence and substitute its own conclusion for that of the disciplinary authority, though it can set aside an order that is not supported by evidence or is perverse. The creation of a Tribunal to deal with such cases does not do away with the requirements of Article 311. If the Tribunal is the forum to which A can go after an adverse order, he should challenge it there on the grounds above. If the Tribunal is itself to hold the inquiry in place of the departmental inquiry, the safeguards of Article 311(2) must still be satisfied.

    7. Relief. If the dismissal is held to be in breach of Article 311, it is liable to be set aside. If it is set aside, A's claim to arrears of salary for the period is sound, since the Supreme Court has held in State of Bihar v Abdul Majid that such a claim is not defeated by the British rule that a servant of the Crown cannot sue for arrears of pay.

    Advice in summary. A should insist on clear charges, supply of the documents and evidence, cross-examination, and a copy of the inquiry report. He should watch the identity of the final dismissing authority, and, if an adverse order is passed, challenge it before the Tribunal or the court on breach of Article 311 or on the ground that it is not supported by evidence.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.