A is in adverse possession of property since 1990. In 2004, A assigns his rights to B and puts B into possession. In 2008, C (registered owner) institutes suit for possession against B. B sets up plea of suit being barred by time for reason of A having been in adverse possession since 1990. C contends that B having come into possession in 2004 only, suit is within time. Decide.
The position rests on a rule which is easily stated. Limitation runs against the owner's right, not against any particular trespasser, so a change in the person who holds the land does not stop the clock, provided the new holder takes over from the old one and the hostile possession continues without a break. If A's possession was adverse from 1990 and B stepped into it in 2004, B may add A's period to his own, and C's suit of 2008 is barred. C's argument, which counts only from B's entry, fails.
A suit by the owner to recover possession of immovable property is governed by Article 65, which allows twelve years from the date when the defendant's possession becomes adverse to the plaintiff. Section 27 then provides that at the determination of the period prescribed for a suit for possession, the right of the person who might have sued is extinguished. The two provisions together mean that once a person has been in hostile possession for twelve years, the owner can no longer sue, and the possessor holds a title that the owner cannot displace. The point of time that matters is therefore the date on which the possession first became adverse, and the question is whether B may rely on A's possession from that date.
He may, if two conditions are met. The first is privity, which means that B must have taken possession from A and not as an independent intruder. The second is continuity, which means that the possession must have been uninterrupted and of the same hostile character before and after the transfer. A trespasser's possession is a fact which can be passed on, and a person who receives it by assignment succeeds to the position of the one who gave it. The Supreme Court has accordingly allowed a person claiming adverse possession to add the possession of his predecessor in interest to his own, in Gurbinder Singh v Lal Singh, AIR 1965 SC 1553 : (1965) 3 SCR 63. The limit on the rule is that the later possession must not be that of an independent trespasser. A stranger who simply enters after the first trespasser has left has no title from him, and his period cannot be joined to the earlier one.
One matter needs to be put right because it is sometimes misstated. It is not necessary that A's twelve years should have been completed before he transferred to B. A successor can tack on whatever period the predecessor had completed, whether or not it was enough by itself. On the facts here the point does not even arise, because the twelve years that began in 1990 were completed in 1990 plus twelve, that is in 2002, which was two years before the assignment. By section 27, C's right was extinguished in 2002. When A assigned his rights in 2004, he passed to B a possession already protected against the owner, and the assignment did not give C a fresh period in which to sue.
C is therefore wrong in saying that the suit is in time because B entered only in 2004. Time began to run against C in 1990, not against B in 2004. The only way in which C could succeed is by showing that the necessary conditions were absent, and on that question the burden lies on B. The law is strict about who has to prove what. A person who pleads adverse possession has no equities in his favour, since he is trying to defeat the right of the true owner, and it is for him to plead and establish every fact needed for the plea: when his possession began, that it was adverse to the owner, that the owner knew of it, how long it continued, and that it was open and undisturbed. This is the rule stated in Mahesh Chand Sharma v Raj Kumari Sharma, (1996) 8 SCC 128. In S.M. Karim v Bibi Sakina, AIR 1964 SC 1254, the Court added that the starting point must be clearly pleaded, and in Kshitish Chandra Bose v Commissioner of Ranchi, AIR 1981 SC 707 : (1981) 2 SCC 103, it was said that the possession must be continuous, open and without concealment. A bare statement that A "had been in possession since 1990" will not do. B must show that the possession was hostile from the beginning, that it was not by licence or permission from C, and that it was handed on to him without interruption. B must also be ready to say that A's possession was the source of his own, because a plea that he came in under a different title would not allow him to rely on A's period.
On proof of these matters, the result is clear. If A's possession from 1990 was open, hostile, exclusive and continuous, and B took over from him in 2004 and held in the same way until the suit, C's suit of 2008 is barred, because the owner's right ended in 2002. The decree for possession must then be refused, and B's title by adverse possession may be set up in defence. If, however, B cannot show that A's possession was adverse, or if it appears that B's own entry was permissive or that the chain was broken, only B's own period counts, and as that is four years the suit is within time and C succeeds. The decisive question is therefore not whether B entered in 2004 but whether the hostile possession which began in 1990 has been established.
Three short illustrations bring out the rule. First, a trespasser takes a plot in 1985 and conveys his possession to another in 1993, and the owner sues in 1999. The twelve years ran out in 1997, so the suit is barred even though the second holder had been there only six years. Second, the owner of a plot is out of possession for the same time, but the person now in occupation came in on his own, with no dealing with the earlier trespasser. Nothing can be added to his period, and a suit brought within twelve years of his own entry is in time. Third, a person occupies land in 1990 with the owner's permission, which the owner withdraws in 2000, and he transfers possession in 2003. Time began only in 2000, because until then the possession was not hostile, and a suit in 2008 is within the twelve years.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
