A is prosecuted for murder of B on 1.1.84. Are the following facts relevant and why: (i) That A being the son of B, needed his inheritance at once. (ii) That A was 300 kilometres away from the scene of occurrence on the date and at the time of alleged incident. (iii) A, when told that police was looking for the murderer of 'B', started running away.
The three facts in this problem are covered by three provisions of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (IEA). They are Section 8 (motive), Section 11 (alibi) and Section 8 again (conduct). In the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) these are Sections 6, 9 and 6. All three facts are relevant.
I. A, the Son of B, Needed His Inheritance at Once
This fact is relevant as motive under Section 8 IEA (Section 6 BSA). The section makes relevant any fact that shows or forms a motive or preparation for a fact in issue or a relevant fact. Here the fact in issue is whether A murdered B on 1 January 1984. If A would inherit from B and needed money at once, that need is the impulse that may have led him to commit the act.
Motive is not the same as intention. Motive is the reason or feeling that pushes a person to act. A son's urgent need for his inheritance makes it more believable, though far from certain, that he had a reason to bring about his father's death. Where a case rests on circumstantial evidence, as murder cases often do, motive is an important link in the chain.
But motive alone proves little. It only raises or lowers the probability of the charge. It is not the charge itself. So the fact is clearly relevant, but how much weight it carries is a separate question.
II. A Was 300 Kilometres Away at the Time of the Incident
This fact is relevant under Section 11 IEA (Section 9 BSA). That section makes relevant the facts that are not otherwise relevant, if they are inconsistent with a fact in issue or a relevant fact, or if they make the existence or non-existence of such a fact highly probable or improbable.
This is the plea of alibi, a Latin word meaning "elsewhere". If A was 300 kilometres away when the murder happened, that is inconsistent with the fact in issue that A committed it. The Act gives a near-identical illustration: the question is whether A committed a crime at Calcutta on a certain day, and the fact that on that day A was at Lahore is relevant. The distance here makes A's presence at the murder highly improbable, or even impossible.
An alibi needs strong proof. The Supreme Court said in Dudh Nath Pandey v. State of U.P. (AIR 1981 SC 911) that the burden of proving guilt never shifts from the prosecution. But an alibi is a fact that the accused himself sets up, so he must prove it with certainty. He must show that he was elsewhere at the time, so that his presence at the scene is ruled out. The plea cannot rest on a bare claim. If he proves it, the prosecution case on his presence falls. If he fails, the failure does not itself prove guilt, because the prosecution must still prove its case by its own evidence.
Section 103 IEA (Section 106 BSA) puts the burden of proving a particular fact on the person who wants the court to believe it. Section 106 IEA (Section 109 BSA) adds that when a fact is especially within a person's knowledge, he must prove it. So A, who pleads the alibi, must first establish it.
III. A Started Running Away When Told That the Police Were Looking for B's Murderer
This is relevant as the accused's later conduct under Section 8 IEA (Section 6 BSA). The section makes relevant the conduct of any party to a proceeding, in reference to a fact in issue or a relevant fact, if the conduct influences or is influenced by that fact, whether it came before or after it. Explanation 2 adds that when a person's conduct is relevant, any statement made to him or in his presence and hearing, which affects that conduct, is also relevant.
The facts are almost the same as Illustration (f) to Section 8. In that illustration the question is whether A robbed B. C says in A's presence that the police are coming to look for the man who robbed B, and A at once runs away. Both the statement and the running away are relevant. In our problem, A is told that the police are looking for B's murderer, and he immediately runs. The statement is relevant because it explains A's conduct. The conduct, that is the flight, is relevant because it may show a guilty mind.
The Supreme Court dealt with this in Thimma v. State of Mysore (AIR 1971 SC 1871). It held that absconding when the police suspect a person is relevant and may point, to some extent, to a guilty mind. But it added a warning. Flight does not lead to only one conclusion. Even an innocent person, when suspected of a serious crime, may try to avoid arrest. In Kartarey v. State of U.P. (AIR 1976 SC 76) the Court held that a person is an absconder in law even if he has not left his home, so long as he hides himself to avoid legal process.
So flight is a relevant circumstance against the accused, but the court must weigh it with all the other evidence. Flight alone cannot support a conviction.
A Summary
| Fact | Relevant Under | Principle |
| A needed his inheritance urgently | S. 8 IEA / S. 6 BSA | Motive: an impulse that makes the act more probable |
| A was 300 km away at the time | S. 11 IEA / S. 9 BSA | Alibi: a fact inconsistent with the fact in issue |
| A ran away on hearing that the police were looking for B's murderer | S. 8 IEA / S. 6 BSA | Later conduct: flight that may show a guilty mind |
None of the three facts is conclusive. The first shows why A may have wanted to kill B. The third shows how A behaved afterwards. The second, if proved, could destroy the prosecution case by placing A elsewhere. Where a case rests on circumstantial evidence, the chain of circumstances must be complete. It must fit with guilt and rule out innocence before there can be a conviction. The Supreme Court stated this in Hanumant Govind Nargundkar v. State of Madhya Pradesh (AIR 1952 SC 343).
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
