A lease for one year containing an option to the tenant to renew for a further period of one year. Is such a lease compulsorily registrable? Explain giving reasons.
A one-year lease with a tenant option to renew for another year is registrable if the option binds the landlord, since the protected term can then exceed one year.
A lease for one year, with an option to the tenant to renew for a further year, raises the question whether the lease is "for a term exceeding one year" under section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908. The answer depends on whose will the renewal depends on.
The starting point. A lease for a single year, which reserves no yearly rent, is outside section 17(1)(d), since the clause reaches leases from year to year, for a term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent. The lease is then optionally registrable under section 18(c), and section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, permits it to be made by oral agreement with delivery of possession.
What an option does. The "term" of a lease for this purpose is the period during which the document protects the tenant in possession. If the tenant alone can decide to continue for a second year, and the landlord is bound to grant the continuation, then the document itself secures the tenant's possession for two years. In substance the lease is for a term that can run beyond one year, and it falls within the clause. The tenant's option is a right created by the document, and it forms part of the interest the document creates in the property.
Where the renewal is not an obligation. If the clause says only that the lease may be renewed if the parties agree, or if the landlord consents, the tenant has nothing beyond the first year. The document protects him for one year only. It need not be registered, and a renewal, if the parties later agree to it, will be tested separately: if the renewed term, together with the first, exceeds one year, the instrument that creates it must be registered.
Related situations. A lease for one year which is to continue until a fresh lease is granted is treated as creating a tenancy that can continue beyond the year, and registration is needed. A lease for eleven months that is renewable only by mutual consent does not require registration, because the tenant has no right to a further period.
The conclusion. A lease for one year with the tenant's option to renew for a further year, where the landlord is bound to grant it, is compulsorily registrable under section 17(1)(d). If the renewal rests on the landlord's consent, it is not. In States where all leases are made registrable, such as Andhra Pradesh, the question does not arise.
If it is not registered. An unregistered lease that required registration cannot be used to prove its terms, including the option. It may be looked at for a collateral purpose, such as the nature of the tenant's possession, and the occupier is generally held to be a tenant from month to month (Anthony v K.C. Ittoop & Sons, (2000) 6 SCC 394).
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
