A minor falsely represented his age, obtained Rs. 10,000 loan and spent on luxuries. Can A be held liable on contract or in tort?
The fundamental principle in Indian contract law, established by the Privy Council in the landmark case of Mohoribibi v Dharmodas Ghose, is that an agreement entered into by a minor is absolutely void ab initio (from the beginning). Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, specifies that a person must be of the age of majority to be competent to contract, which a minor is not. The law's rationale is to protect minors from their own poor judgment, ignorance, and immaturity.
Applying this principle to the present case:
(a) Will suit by A (the minor) to set aside mortgage succeed?
Yes, a suit by A (the minor) to set aside the mortgage will likely succeed.
The mortgage agreement entered into by A is void because A was a minor at the time. A void agreement has no legal effect whatsoever.
The fact that A fraudulently misrepresented his age does not change the void nature of the agreement. There is no estoppel against a minor, even if they have acted fraudulently or misrepresented their age. The minor is not prevented from pleading minority. The doctrine of estoppel (Section 115, Evidence Act (now Section 121, Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023)) cannot be used to defeat a statutory provision (like the Contract Act) that declares a minor's contract void. This was settled in cases like Sadiq Ali Khan v Jai Kishore and confirmed in Mohoribibi v Dharmodas Ghose.
A minor who has entered into a void agreement, even by misrepresenting age, can seek a declaration that the agreement is void.
The relief of cancellation of the mortgage deed can be granted under the Specific Relief Act, 1877 (Section 39) or the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (Section 31, which replaces Section 39). In the Mohoribibi case, the minor sought cancellation of the mortgage, and the court held that this relief had to be granted as the plaintiff was entitled to it. A document which is void ab initio can be set aside.
(b) Can B (the lender) recover from A (the minor)?
B cannot recover the money from A based on the contract or as damages for fraud arising out of the contract. However, there is a limited possibility of recovery under the principle of equitable restitution as clarified by the Specific Relief Act, 1963, but this depends entirely on whether the money provided a tangible benefit to the minor or his estate.
No Contractual Liability: Since the mortgage agreement and the loan promise within it are absolutely void, B cannot enforce the repayment of the loan under contract law. Sections 64 and 65 of the Contract Act, dealing with restitution in voidable or void contracts, do not apply to a minor's agreement because it is void ab initio and there was never a contract between competent parties.
No Liability in Tort Arising from Contract: While a minor can generally be liable in tort, they cannot be held liable for a tort if it arises out of a contract. Making the minor liable for fraud (a tort) to compel repayment of the loan amount would be an indirect way of enforcing the void contract. English cases like Johnson v Pye and Leslie (R) Ltd v Sheill supported this view, holding that an infant obtaining a loan by false representation could not be made to repay the amount as damages for deceit, as "restitution stopped where repayment began".
Equitable Restitution under Specific Relief Act, 1963:
Historically, under English law, restitution of money obtained by a minor's fraud was not permitted, especially if the money was spent and not traceable. This was the position reflected in cases like Leslie (R) Ltd v Sheill.
In India, before 1963, there was a conflict of opinion, with some courts ordering refund of money received by a minor (e.g., Khan Gul v Lakha Singh for money received for selling land), while others refused (e.g., Ajudhia Prasad v Chandan Lal and Gokeda v Bhimayya for money on mortgage or promissory notes).
The Specific Relief Act, 1963, particularly Section 33, clarified the position. Section 33(2)(b) is relevant when the minor is the defendant (resisting B's attempt to recover). It states that if a defendant successfully resists a suit on the ground of being incompetent to contract, the court may require them to restore such benefits to the other party, to the extent he or his estate has benefited thereby. This allows for monetary compensation.
However, the recovery under Section 33(2)(b) is limited to the "benefit" received. This benefit must be a tangible or permanent benefit to the minor or his estate. Examples of permanent benefits include money spent on education or purchasing assets like a scooter. Examples of temporary benefits, which are not recoverable, include money spent on entertainment, eating, or drinking.
In the above scenario, the Rs. 10,000 loan was spent on "luxuries" [User query], which equate to transient expenses like "entertaining his friends in a Five-star Hotel" or "eating and drinking". Such expenses are considered not a permanent benefit to the minor's estate.
Therefore, B cannot recover the Rs. 10,000 from A because:
The contract is void.
A cannot be sued for fraud as it arises from the void contract.
While equitable restitution is possible for benefits received by a minor defendant under Section 33(2)(b), money spent on "luxuries" or entertainment is not considered a permanent benefit recoverable under this section. B would only be able to recover if the money (or a part of it) could be shown to have provided a lasting benefit to A or his estate.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
