Family LawHindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act 19 May 2026· 5 min read

    A mother gives her minor son in adoption though father is alive. Validity under any circumstances.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The General Rule: Father Has Priority

    The Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, as amended by the Personal Laws Amendment Act, 2010, enacts in Section 9(2) that both the father and the mother, if alive, have an equal right to give a son or daughter in adoption. However, this right shall not be exercised by either of them save with the consent of the other. Under the pre-2010 position, the father had the sole primary right, and the mother could give the child in adoption only in the absence or incapacity of the father. The 2010 amendment placed them on equal footing, but it did not give the mother the right to give the child unilaterally while the father is alive and competent. The requirement of the other parent's consent remains absolute.

    A straightforward application of this principle compels one conclusion: a mother who gives her minor son in adoption while the father is alive, without his consent, performs an act that is void under Section 5(1) of the Act, which declares that any adoption made in contravention of the provisions of the chapter shall be void.

    The Three Exceptions: When the Mother May Act Alone

    The Act itself carves out three specific situations where the mother's independent power to give the child in adoption revives even while the father is biologically alive. These exceptions, found in the proviso to Section 9(2), are:

    • If the father has completely and finally renounced the world by entering a religious order (yati or sanyasi), not a mere withdrawal from family life, but a final and complete severance from worldly affairs

    • If the father has ceased to be a Hindu by converting to another religion such as Islam or Christianity

    • If the father has been declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be of unsound mind, and it is critical to note that mere factual insanity is not enough; there must be a judicial declaration by a court

    In any of these three circumstances, the father's right and voice are extinguished by operation of law, and the mother may give the child in adoption entirely on her own authority. In these cases his dissent carries no weight.

    A Crucial Distinction: Factual Insanity vs. Judicial Declaration

    The distinction between factual insanity and judicial declaration of unsound mind is not a mere technicality, it is a substantive safeguard. The Act is explicit that if the father is in fact of unsound mind but has not been adjudged as such by a competent court, the mother cannot give the child in adoption. Strict proof of the giving and taking, and of compliance with Section 9, was insisted on in Dhanraj v. Suraj Bai (AIR 1973 Raj 7, affirmed AIR 1975 SC 1103). The requirement of a court declaration is designed to prevent a mother from unilaterally deciding that the father is mentally incapacitated, a determination of such gravity must have the seal of judicial authority.

    The Special Case: Conversion of the Father

    When the father converts to a non-Hindu religion, a notable consequence follows. On his conversion, the power to give the child in adoption passes to the mother alone, and she can exercise it without his consent and even despite his protest. This is because a person who has ceased to be a Hindu is disqualified from participating in the adoption process under the Act, which is a specifically Hindu personal law statute. it is settled that a parent does not cease to be a Hindu by merely repudiating the faith or living an unorthodox life, formal conversion to a non-Hindu faith such as Islam, Christianity, or Zoroastrianism is necessary.

    The Illegitimate Son: A Distinct Position

    The case of an illegitimate son is different. The Explanation to Section 9 excludes only the adoptive father and mother from the meaning of "father" and "mother", and says nothing of a putative father. The Act does not say expressly who gives an illegitimate child in adoption. It is argued that, because an illegitimate child is related to his mother (Section 3(1)(j) of the Hindu Succession Act), the mother can give the child without the putative father's consent, but this rests on reasoning and not on an express provision, and the point is not settled.

    Summary of Valid Circumstances

    To state the legal position with precision: a mother giving her legitimate minor son in adoption while the father is alive will be valid only in the following circumstances:

    CircumstanceValidity of Mother's Act
    Father alive and capacitatedVoid, father's consent is mandatory
    Father has ceased to be Hindu by conversionValid, mother may act alone, even against his protest
    Father has completely and finally renounced the worldValid, mother may act alone
    Father judicially declared to be of unsound mindValid, mother may act alone
    Father factually insane but no court declarationVoid, judicial declaration is a precondition
    Father alive but divorced / separated / deserted motherVoid, marital status is irrelevant to parental right
    Son is illegitimateArguably valid, no express provision; not settled

    The Act leaves no room for expansion of these exceptions by courts or by equitable reasoning. When the conditions under which consent may be dispensed with are specified, taking any other plea, as the Karnataka High Court noted in Siddaramappa v. Gouravva (AIR 2004 Kant 230), would amount to adding words to the statute. See Q.58 for the case of a divorced mother.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.