A obtained a loan from a bank. Bank asked A to furnish security. A accordingly executed a mortgage deed in favour of the bank. The mortgage deed was duly registered before the Sub-Registrar. Later on the bank came to know that the mortgage deed was deficiently stamped, deficiency being to the tune of Rs. 79,000/-. The Sub-Registrar issued a notice to A calling upon him to pay the deficient Court fee. A challenged the said notice before High Court in a writ petition contending that after registration the sub-registrar became functus officio. So no such notice asking him to make up the deficiency in Court fee could be issued by the Sub-Registrar. How would you deal with this plea of the petitioner?
After registration the Sub-Registrar cannot reopen registration, but deficient stamp duty is recovered through the Collector under the Stamp Act, not as court fee.
The petitioner's plea is partly right and partly wrong. The Sub-Registrar is functus officio so far as registration is concerned, but the registration of a document does not prevent the deficiency in stamp duty from being recovered. The way to recover it is through the machinery of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, and a demand for "court fee" is not the correct demand.
What functus officio covers. Once a document has been registered, the Sub-Registrar has done what the Registration Act required of him. He cannot cancel the registration, re-open it, or withhold the document on the ground of the stamp deficiency. A document that is insufficiently stamped can be presented and registered, and the presentation is a good presentation; the Registration Act does not make sufficiency of stamp duty a condition of registration.
Recovery under the Stamp Act. The consequence of deficient stamp duty is separate. Under section 33 of the Stamp Act, every person in charge of a public office before whom an instrument chargeable with duty is produced or comes in the performance of his functions must impound it if it is not duly stamped. Under section 35, an instrument not duly stamped cannot be admitted in evidence or acted upon until the duty and penalty are paid. The impounded instrument is sent to the Collector, who determines the deficiency and the penalty after hearing the party (sections 38 and 40). In States that have inserted section 47A, there is a procedure for reference to the Collector where the market value of the property has been undervalued in the instrument.
Stamp duty and court fee. A notice that calls on A to pay "deficient court fee" confuses two different levies. Court fee is payable on plaints and other proceedings in courts under the Court Fees Act. Stamp duty is payable on instruments under the Stamp Act. The deficiency here, on a mortgage deed, is one of stamp duty.
How the plea should be dealt with. The writ petition should not be allowed on the ground that registration made the Sub-Registrar functus officio, since the bank and the State can recover the deficiency. The notice, as framed by the Sub-Registrar, is not the order of the authority that the Stamp Act empowers to fix the deficiency and penalty. The correct course is for the instrument to be dealt with by the Collector, who must give the petitioner an opportunity to be heard before determining the amount payable. The High Court may therefore direct that the Sub-Registrar's notice be treated as setting that process in motion, quash the demand in its present form, and leave the Collector to determine the duty and penalty under the Stamp Act.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
