A offered to buy flour from B requesting that acceptance should be sent by wagon. B sent acceptance by post. Letter arrived after wagon time. Is A bound?
In the present case where A offered to buy flour from B requesting that acceptance should be sent by wagon, and B sent acceptance by post which arrived after the time the wagon would have, A is not bound by the acceptance, provided he promptly insists on acceptance by wagon within a reasonable time (Section 7(2)); if he stays silent, he is taken to have accepted the acceptance and the contract is concluded.
Prescribed Mode of Acceptance: Generally, acceptance has to be made in the manner prescribed or indicated by the offeror.
Relevant Case Law: This principle is illustrated by the American case of Ellison v Henshaw (1819) 4 Wheaton 225.
Indian Law (Section 7): Section 7 of the Indian Contract Act provides that if the acceptance is not made in the prescribed manner, the offeror must object to this departure within a reasonable time. If the offeror fails to object, the contract is formed despite the acceptance not being in the prescribed mode.
Application: While Section 7 in India puts a duty on the offeror to object to a different mode, that when the deviation from the prescribed mode also results in the acceptance arriving later than it would have by the requested mode, the offeror is not bound. The offeror, having requested acceptance by wagon, is entitled to expect it by that mode or by an equally expeditious mode arriving within the same timeframe. Since the postal acceptance arrived after the expected time by wagon, it wasn't effective acceptance that could bind A. Under English law, a mode of acceptance that is equally effective for the offeror will generally suffice unless the offeror insists that only the prescribed mode will do (Yates Building Co Ltd v R J Pulleyn & Sons (York) Ltd (1975) 237 EG 183).
Therefore, relying on Section 7 of Indian Contract Act and the case law provided above, A is not bound, provided he promptly insists on the prescribed mode within a reasonable time (Section 7(2)); if he stays silent he is deemed to have accepted the acceptance. His insistence is justified because the acceptance was not sent by the requested mode (wagon) and, crucially, arrived late when sent by the different mode (post).
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
