Contract ActOffer and Acceptance 12 May 2026· 3 min read

    A offered to buy nephew F's horse for Rs. 10,000 adding "If I hear no more, I shall consider horse mine at Rs. 10,000". No answer returned but F told auctioneer to keep horse out of sale. Auctioneer sold by mistake. A sues F. Decide

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.
    1. Requirement of Communication of Acceptance: For an agreement to become a binding contract, there must be an offer and a valid acceptance. A crucial requirement for a valid acceptance is that it must be communicated to the offeror. According to Section 4 of the Indian Contract Act, the communication of a proposal is complete when it comes to the knowledge of the person to whom it is made. Similarly, the communication of acceptance is complete against the proposer when it is put in a course of transmission to him. However, until the acceptance is communicated to the offeror, there is no completed contract.

    2. Silence is Not Acceptance: Mere silence cannot be a mode of acceptance of a proposal. Silence does not generally constitute acceptance of an offer. An offeror cannot impose upon the offeree the 'burden of refusal'. This means that A stating "If I hear no more about the horse, I consider the horse mine" is not a valid condition that can create a contract if F simply remains silent.

    3. Communication to a Stranger is Ineffective: Acceptance of an offer should be communicated to the offeror himself or his authorized agent. A communication to a stranger will not suffice. In this scenario, F told his auctioneer (a stranger to the contract between A and F) not to sell the horse. This internal instruction or communication to the auctioneer was not a communication of acceptance to A.

    4. Relevant Case Law - Felthouse v Bindley: This scenario is a classic illustration of the principle that silence does not amount to acceptance and that acceptance must be communicated to the offeror. In Felthouse v Bindley (1862) 11 CB (NS) 869, the plaintiff (A in the present scenario) offered to buy his nephew's horse (F in the present scenario), stating: "If I hear no more about the horse, I consider the horse mine at £33-15s". The nephew sent no reply but told his auctioneer not to sell the horse as it was already sold to his uncle. The auctioneer sold the horse by mistake. The court held that there was no contract between the uncle and the nephew. The nephew had not communicated his intention to the uncle. The court laid down the proposition that an offeror can't impose upon the offeree the 'burden of refusal', and mere silence cannot be a mode of acceptance. (In Felthouse the uncle sued the auctioneer in conversion, not the nephew; the claim failed because no contract, and therefore no property in the horse, had passed to the uncle.)

    Applying these principles, F's silence did not constitute acceptance of A's offer. F's instruction to his auctioneer, while indicating his intention, was not a communication of acceptance to A. Since there was no communication of acceptance from F to A, no binding contract was formed for the sale of the horse.

    Therefore, A cannot successfully sue F for breach of contract because no contract came into existence. The auctioneer's sale was a mistake, but it does not retroactively create a contract between A and F. A's claim against F could only be for breach of contract (non-delivery of the horse), and that fails for want of a concluded contract. Conversion, if it lay at all, would lie against the auctioneer who sold the horse, as in Felthouse itself, and would fail for the same reason.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.