A owes a sum of Rs. 200/- to B on a pronote. Before the expiry of the period of limitation A pays a sum of Rs. 100/- to B towards that pronote. What is the effect of this payment on limitation?
The position is governed by section 19, which gives a fresh period when a payment on account of a debt is made before the prescribed period expires. The effect depends on one condition, which the facts do not mention, and which is whether A's payment was acknowledged in writing.
Assume that the pronote is payable on demand. Article 35 then gives three years, running from the date of the note. Suppose the note is dated 3 April 2014, so that the period would end on 3 April 2017. On 20 February 2017, before that date, A pays Rs 100 on account of the note. The payment is made in time, by the person liable, and it is a payment of part of the principal of a debt, which is a payment "on account of a debt" within section 19.
If A's payment appears in his own handwriting or in a writing he has signed, as when he endorses "received Rs 100 on account" and signs, or gives a signed receipt, the proviso to section 19 is satisfied. A fresh period of limitation then runs from the date of payment, 20 February 2017, and B has until 20 February 2020 to sue for the balance of Rs 100. It is the payment that starts the new period; the writing proves it. If A paid on 20 February 2017 and signed the endorsement a week later, time would still run from 20 February.
If there is no such writing, the payment has no effect on limitation. The proviso is a condition of the benefit, and a payment that cannot be shown to have been acknowledged in A's handwriting or signed writing leaves the original period untouched. The period would then run out on 3 April 2017 as though no payment had been made, and a suit filed afterwards would be barred, even if B could prove the payment by other evidence. Only a separate signed promise to pay, of the kind section 25(3) of the Contract Act enforces, could then help him. The burden of proving the payment and the writing is on B, who is the party relying on the section (Sant Lal Mahton v Kamla Prasad, AIR 1951 SC 477).
The extension is also limited to the person who paid. If A is the sole maker of the note, no difficulty arises. If the note was made jointly with others, section 20(2) provides that a payment by one of several joint contractors does not make the others chargeable merely because he paid, unless he acted as their authorised agent.
The advice to B is therefore to see to it that every part payment on the note is endorsed on the note itself, or receipted, in a form that A signs at the time. Then the Rs 100 that remains outstanding can be recovered within three years of the date of payment.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
