A published an advertisement for selling his house at a price of Rs. 15 lakhs. A declined to sell his house to B who was ready to pay Rs. 15 lakhs as price of house of A. A sold his house to C who agreed to pay price of Rs. 20 lakhs. Whether B can sue A for purchase of house?
The above question deals with Offer and Invitation to offer:
Distinction between Offer and Invitation to Offer/Treat: In contract law, it's crucial to distinguish between an offer and an invitation to offer (sometimes called an invitation to treat). An offer is a definite proposal made with the intention of being bound if accepted. An invitation to offer, however, is merely an indication of willingness to negotiate or to receive offers. It does not create a legal obligation to deal with anyone who responds.
Advertisement as Invitation to Offer: Generally, advertisements for the sale of property or goods are considered invitations to offer. They are meant to invite interested parties to make offers, rather than constituting a binding offer that can be accepted by anyone who sees the advertisement and expresses assent to the price mentioned. An advertisement may, however, amount to an offer where it shows a definite intention to be bound (Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256); a bare advertisement of a house for sale at a stated price shows no such intention.
B's Action as an Offer: In this scenario, A's advertisement for selling his house at Rs. 15 lakhs is likely an invitation to offer. B's response, indicating readiness to pay Rs. 15 lakhs, is therefore not an acceptance, but rather an offer made by B to A.
Freedom to Accept or Reject Offers: Since B's statement is an offer, A is not bound to accept it. A retains the freedom to consider other offers and accept the one that is most favorable, as was done by accepting C's offer of Rs. 20 lakhs.
Relevant Case Laws:
McPherson v Appana [AIR 1951 SC 184] is a relevant case. In this case, the plaintiff offered Rs. 6,000 for a lodge. The agent replied, "Won't accept less than Rs. 10,000". The plaintiff then purported to accept the Rs. 10,000 price. The Supreme Court held that the agent's reply was not an offer or counter-offer, but merely an invitation to make offers. There was no concluded contract because there was no assent to the plaintiff's offer to buy at Rs. 10,000. This supports the principle that stating a price is not necessarily an offer to sell at that price, but might just be setting a minimum or inviting negotiation.
Harvey v Facey (1893) AC 552 is another leading case cited, relied upon in McPherson v Appana. In this case, the plaintiff asked if the defendant would sell a property and asked for the lowest cash price. The defendant replied stating the lowest price. The court held that merely stating the lowest price in response to an inquiry was not an offer to sell, but simply providing information. The plaintiff's subsequent telegram purporting to "agree to buy" was itself the offer, which the defendant never accepted. This case reinforces that merely mentioning a price does not create an offer capable of being accepted to form a contract.
Conclusion: Applying these principles, A's advertisement was an invitation for offers. B's agreement to pay Rs. 15 lakhs was an offer. A was free to accept or reject B's offer and chose to accept a different offer from C. Since no contract was concluded between A and B (as A did not accept B's offer), B has no legal grounds to sue A for breach of contract for not selling the house to him.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
