A purchased a plot from NOIDA. Sale deed was signed by the vendee and attesting witnesses on 26.12.84 and by the Administrator of NOIDA on 14.02.85. The deed was not presented for registration as it was not executed "for and on behalf of Governor of U.P". On 01.07.86 Administrator added words "on behalf of Governor of U.P." under his signature. When presented, Sub-Registrar refused the deed on the ground that it was not presented for registration "within four months from the date of its execution" as required by section 23 of the Registration Act. Do you agree with him. Decide and give reasons.
The four months in section 23 run from the last execution; if the Administrator signed in the proper capacity only on 1 July 1986, presentation was in time.
The Sub-Registrar's refusal on the ground of delay depends on one question: when was the sale deed executed? Whether the four months of section 23 of the Registration Act, 1908 ran from 14 February 1985, when the Administrator signed, or only from 1 July 1986, when he added the words showing that he signed on behalf of the Governor, decides the matter.
What execution means. A document is executed when the person who is bound by it signs it with the intention to be bound, in the capacity in which he is to be bound. The vendee and the attesting witnesses signed on 26 December 1984, and the Administrator on 14 February 1985. The signatures of attesting witnesses do not count as execution, since they only attest. Execution of the sale deed on the vendor's side was by the Administrator, who could bind the authority only if he signed for and on behalf of the Governor, as the deed required.
Section 24. Where a document is executed by several persons at different times, it may be presented within four months from the date of each execution. The vendee executed on 26 December 1984, and the vendor on 14 February 1985 or on 1 July 1986, depending on the answer above.
Two possible conclusions. If the Administrator's signature on 14 February 1985 was an execution of the deed, the last execution was on that date, and time expired on 14 June 1985. Section 25 could extend it by at most four months to 14 October 1985, and only on proof of urgent necessity or unavoidable accident. The presentation after July 1986 would then be too late. If, on the other hand, the Administrator's signature without the capacity words did not execute the deed on behalf of the vendor, the deed was not executed by the vendor until the words were added on 1 July 1986. The four months then ran from that date and presentation within that period was in time.
Decision. On the better view, the second approach is correct. An officer of a statutory authority acts only in the capacity stated in the deed. A signature that does not show he is acting for the Governor does not complete the vendor's execution. The deed was therefore executed on 1 July 1986, and the Sub-Registrar was wrong to refuse it for delay, provided it was presented within four months of that date. The mere addition of words to an existing deed does not alter the date of the signature already given by the vendee, but the vendor's execution, being the last, governs under section 24. If the Sub-Registrar still refuses, the claimant's remedy is an appeal to the Registrar under section 72.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
