A sells a piece of land for 99/- to B on 4th January, 1973 by means of an unregistered sale-deed. On 5th February 1974 he (A) sold the same very land to C by means of a registered sale-deed. Who out of B and C shall be owner of the aforesaid land?
On a Rs 99 sale, B prevails only if possession was delivered under section 54 TPA; otherwise C registered deed takes priority under section 50.
A sells land to B for Rs 99 by an unregistered deed on 4 January 1973, and sells the same land to C by a registered deed on 5 February 1974. The answer depends on whether the transfer to B was complete before the sale to C, and for that the value of the property and the manner of the transfer both matter.
Registration is optional below Rs 100. Section 17(1)(b) makes registration compulsory only for instruments dealing with immovable property of a value of one hundred rupees or more. A deed relating to a right worth Rs 99 falls within section 18(a), and registration is optional. The deed in B's favour is therefore not hit by section 49 for want of registration.
But a sale must still satisfy section 54. Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 says that a transfer of ownership in tangible immovable property of a value of less than one hundred rupees may be made either by a registered instrument or by delivery of the property. Registration is not required in the sense of the Registration Act, but the transfer must still be completed in one of those two ways. An unregistered deed alone, without delivery of possession, does not complete the sale. The first question, then, is whether A delivered possession to B.
If possession was delivered to B. The sale was complete on delivery in 1973 and B became the owner. A then had nothing to sell to C in 1974, and C acquired no title by his registered deed. Section 50(1) does not help C, since it gives a registered document priority over an unregistered document, and B's title rests on a completed transfer, not merely on the unregistered paper.
If possession was not delivered. B's deed is unregistered and there was no delivery, so the sale to B was incomplete. Section 50(1) then applies. A registered document of the kinds in section 17(1)(a) to (d) and section 18(a) and (b) takes effect, as regards the property, against every unregistered document relating to the same property, whether it is of the same nature or not, and whether it was executed earlier or later. C's registered deed, being a document of the kind in section 18(a), takes effect against B's unregistered deed, and C becomes the owner.
Conclusion. C is the owner unless B proves that possession of the land was delivered to him with the sale. The burden of proving delivery lies on B, since without it his title is incomplete.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
