A singer contracts with theatre for 2 nights/week for 2 months at Rs. 500/night. On 6th night A willfully absents, B rescinds contract. Rights of parties?
The general rule is that parties to a contract must either perform or offer to perform their respective promises, unless performance is dispensed with or excused. This obligation is stated in Section 37 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
In the scenario, the singer (A) has made a promise to sing at the theatre for two nights a week for two months. By willfully absenting herself on the sixth night, A has refused to perform her promise.
This situation falls under Section 39 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. This section deals with the effect of a party's refusal to perform their promise wholly. It provides that when a party to a contract has refused to perform, or disabled himself from performing his promise in its entirety, the promisee (B, the theatre manager) may put an end to the contract, unless he has indicated by words or conduct his agreement to the contract continuing. The case of Sooltan Chand v Schillar, ILR (1879) 4 Cal 252, observed that even absence on one night, constitutes a breach of the contract in its entirety.
Therefore, when the singer (A) willfully absents herself on the sixth night, she has committed a breach of contract by refusing to perform her promise wholly. This gives the theatre manager (B) the right to rescind the contract. Rescission is the revocation or abrogation of a contract, which discharges a party from their obligations under the agreement.
Regarding the rights and obligations of the parties after rescission:
Rights of the Theatre Manager (B):
B has the right to put an end to the contract due to A's refusal to perform her promise in its entirety.
B is entitled to claim compensation for any damage which he has sustained through the non-fulfillment of the contract. This right to claim compensation upon rightfully rescinding a contract is provided under Section 75 of the Indian Contract Act. The illustration under Section 75 uses the same singer/theatre scenario and states that B is entitled to claim compensation for damages sustained.
Obligations of the Theatre Manager (B) and Rights of the Singer (A):
When a party rescinds a contract, they generally have an obligation to restore any benefit received under the contract.
Section 65 in relation to a party who has received an advantage under a contract that becomes void, requiring restoration or compensation. Illustration (c) under Section 65 explicitly addresses the singer/theatre scenario (the illustration uses Rs. 100 per night; on the figures in this problem, Rs. 500 per night, the five nights sung come to Rs. 2,500) and states that after B rescinds the contract, B must pay A for the five nights on which she had sung. This indicates that the benefit received by B (the performances on the previous five nights) must be compensated or restored.
Similarly, Section 64 lays down that a party rescinding a voidable contract must restore any benefit received. Since a breach under Section 39 makes the contract voidable at the option of the innocent party, Section 64 could also be relevant in principle, requiring B to restore benefits. The principle of restitution or compensation is also embodied in Sections 19A and 64 of the Indian Contract Act.
In summary, when the singer (A) willfully breaches the contract by absenting herself, the theatre manager (B) has the right to terminate the contract under Section 39. B is also entitled to claim compensation for the damages suffered due to the breach under Section 75. However, B is obligated under the principles of restitution (as illustrated by Section 65 and potentially Section 64) to pay the singer (A) for the performances she had completed before the breach occurred.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
