'A' sold a house to 'B' for Rs. 1,00,000/- on 3.3.2011. 'A' retained the possession of the house. On 7.3.2011, 'A' again sold the same house to 'C' for a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/-. 'C' was aware of the earlier sale between 'A' and 'B'. The sale deed in favour of 'C' was got registered on the same day and 'C' was also given the physical possession of the house. The sale deed in favour of 'B' was got registered on 10.4.2011. 'B' thereafter filed a suit for recovery of possession of the house against 'A' and 'C'. Decide.
Where two sale deeds are both registered, section 47 relates each back to its execution, so B first sale of 3 March 2011 prevails over C.
A sells a house to B for Rs 1,00,000 on 3 March 2011, retaining possession. On 7 March 2011, A sells it to C for Rs 2,00,000. C knows of the earlier sale. C's deed is registered on the same day, and C gets possession. B's deed is registered on 10 April 2011. B sues A and C for possession. B succeeds.
Both documents are registered. Section 50(1) gives a registered document priority over an unregistered one. It does not decide between two registered documents, and so it does not help C merely because C registered first. The two deeds have to be compared under section 47.
Section 47: relation back. A registered document operates from the time at which it would have begun to operate if no registration had been required, and not from the time of its registration. A sale deed would have operated from the date of its execution. B's sale deed, executed on 3 March 2011, operates from that date, even though registered on 10 April. B's deed was presented well within the four months allowed by section 23, and nothing in the facts shows a defect in it. On 7 March, A had already parted with the house, and had nothing left to convey to C.
Possession and notice do not alter the result. C was given possession and registered quickly. These facts would matter if C were competing with an unregistered deed, or if B's sale were unregistered. They do not defeat a registered deed that operates from an earlier date. C's knowledge of the earlier sale also makes his position weaker on the equities, but the decision does not need to rest on notice. Section 48 does not apply, since it concerns oral agreements and declarations.
Decision. B is the owner by virtue of the earlier sale, and is entitled to recover possession from C, as A's title passed to B on 3 March 2011 and C obtained none. C may look to A for the return of the purchase money paid, together with damages, on A's breach of the covenants of title under section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
