A, the landlord filed an eviction petition against his tenant B under Rent Control Act. During the pendency of the eviction petition he also filed a suit for injunction seeking to restrain the tenant from carrying out any additions/alterations in the demised premises. In this suit, a compromise was arrived at. In terms of compromise, the landlord agreed to withdraw the eviction petition and also to carry out some additions/alterations to the satisfaction of tenant. The tenant agreed to enhance the rent and to vacate the premises after 10 years from the date of compromise. After the expiry of 10 years, when the Landlord applied for execution of compromise decree, the tenant opposed the same on the ground that the compromise amounted to creation of a fresh tenancy involving enhancement of rent and enlargement of demised premises. It was contended that compromise deed was required to be registered both under section 17(1)(d) of Registration Act as well as under section 107 of T.P. Act and since it was not so registered, it remains unenforceable. Decide the plea of the tenant.
A compromise decree creating a fresh ten-year tenancy may need registration, but it cannot be resisted in execution after the tenant took its benefits.
The tenant's plea has some force on the registration point, but it fails at the stage of execution. The decree cannot be questioned there, and the tenant, having taken the benefits of the compromise, cannot resist it.
Whether the compromise needed registration. Section 17(2)(vi) exempts decrees and orders of court from registration, except a decree or order made on a compromise and comprising immovable property other than the subject matter of the suit. The Supreme Court has explained that the exemption covers decrees that declare or confirm rights that already existed. A compromise decree that creates a fresh right in immovable property for the first time is not meant to be exempt, and parties cannot use a compromise decree as a device to avoid the registration and stamp duty that the document would have attracted (Bhoop Singh v Ram Singh Major, (1995) 5 SCC 709). A lease falls under clause (d) of section 17(1), and section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 requires a registered instrument for a lease for a term exceeding one year. Here, the compromise fixed a new rent, contemplated alterations, and set a term of ten years. It looks like a fresh lease, and the tenant's argument that it needed registration has substance.
Why the tenant still fails. First, the landlord is not trying to prove the terms of a lease from an unregistered document. He is applying to execute a decree passed by a competent court that has become final. The execution court enforces the decree as it stands. It cannot go behind it, and a decree founded on a document that needed registration is not a nullity. It may be open to challenge in appeal or revision, but not in execution. Secondly, the tenant took the benefit of the compromise. The eviction petition was withdrawn, the alterations were made to his satisfaction, and he enjoyed the premises for ten years. A person who has accepted such benefits cannot afterwards say the arrangement was unenforceable for want of registration. Thirdly, the same compromise contains the tenant's own promise to vacate after ten years, and a promise of this kind made to the court is enforceable by execution.
Terms of an unregistered lease. The rule that the terms of a lease required to be registered are not a collateral purpose (Satish Chand Makhan v Goverdhan Das Byas, (1984) 1 SCC 369) applies in a suit based on the document. It does not apply to an execution proceeding on a decree.
Decision. The tenant's objection is rejected, and the decree is executable.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
