Limitation ActCondonation of Delay 06 July 2026· 4 min read

    Admittedly there was wide-spread strike by non-gazetted officers between 5th September to 13th October, 1980. State filed an appeal on 18th October, 1980. Period of limitation had expired on 12th October, 1980. Application was filed for condonation of delay on ground of general strike. How would you decide?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The delay should be condoned, provided the State's affidavit shows what the strike prevented and how the days after it were used. The reasoning follows.

    The appeal was filed on 18 October 1980 and the period ended on 12 October, so on the facts as given the delay is six days. Section 5 applies, because this is an appeal. The State must satisfy the court of sufficient cause under that section, and the Supreme Court said in Ramlal, Motilal and Chotelal v Rewa Coalfields Ltd (AIR 1962 SC 361) that the explanation must cover the failure to file on the last day of the period and the time after it. In Ajit Singh Thakur Singh v State of Gujarat (AIR 1981 SC 733 : (1981) 1 SCC 495) the Court said that a party who allows the period to expire and pleads sufficient cause must show some event or circumstance arising before the expiry that made it impossible to file in time, and that events after the expiry can explain only the further delay. The strike began on 5 September and continued to 13 October, so it covered the last five weeks of the period, and the cause is therefore one that arose within it. That meets the requirement in Ajit Singh, and the date on which the strike ended falls one day after the period expired.

    There is a point on the calendar. 12 October 1980 was a Sunday. If the courts of the State were closed on that day, section 4 would have allowed the appeal to be filed on Monday 13 October, and the delay would be five days, not six, running from 14 to 18 October. The State would not need section 5 for the Sunday, but it would still need it for those five days, and the strike continued through 13 October. A court deciding the case would check this first, though the facts leave it open whether the court was closed.

    A strike is not a sufficient cause just because it happened. The question is whether it actually disabled the people who had to act. For an appeal by the State, the file must be examined, an opinion obtained, sanction given and a memorandum drawn and signed, and if the officers who did those things were on strike, or if the offices that handle them were not working, then a strike of non-gazetted staff can well explain why the appeal was not filed. The affidavit should therefore say who was responsible for the file, what each person did and when, why the appeal could not be filed before the strike ended, and what was done between 14 and 18 October. A bare statement that there was a general strike will not do. In a case reported at (1986) 2 ARC 478, a revision was filed a couple of days after a strike by district advocates and the dismissal of the condonation application for want of an explanation of each day was held improper, which shows the courts do not insist on an hour-by-hour account where the cause is substantial and the delay short.

    The State has no special position. The authorities, including Special Tehsildar, Land Acquisition, Kerala v K.V. Ayisumma ((1996) 10 SCC 634) and State of Haryana v Chandra Mani ((1996) 3 SCC 132), say that the State is treated like any litigant under section 5, but that the court may recognise the way government offices work. In Postmaster General v Living Media India Ltd (AIR 2012 SC 1506 : (2012) 3 SCC 563), a later decision, the Supreme Court held that departmental processing of files does not by itself explain delay. The State here does not rely on routine processing. It relies on an external event that stopped the machinery, and the delay after it is five or six days.

    If the affidavit shows these things, the delay should be condoned. The strike covered the whole of the last five weeks and the end of the period, the delay is six days at most, and the appeal was filed within five days of the strike ending. If instead the affidavit were silent about the file and showed that the department had it ready before 12 October yet waited until 18 October without reason, the strike would not explain the delay and the application should be refused. The decision on the facts as stated in the question is that the delay is condoned and the appeal admitted.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.