Family LawHindu Marriage Act 18 May 2026· 5 min read

    Can a court refuse to pass a decree of divorce despite proof of grounds?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The Philosophy Behind the Bars

    Matrimonial proceedings are not ordinary civil suits. The court is not bound to grant relief merely because the petitioner has proved a ground. Section 23(1) provides that the court shall decree relief only "then, and in such a case, but not otherwise" when its conditions are met, so a ground is necessary but not sufficient. The petitioner must come with clean hands and must not be complicit in the wrong complained of. The conditions are in clauses (a) to (e).

    The Bars Under Section 23

    Taking advantage of one's own wrong or disability is the first bar, in Section 23(1)(a). A petitioner who is responsible for the respondent's wrong cannot turn his own misconduct into a cause of action. In Hirachand Srinivas Managaonkar v. Sunanda (AIR 2001 SC 1285), the husband had obtained judicial separation on the ground of his adultery, continued to live in adultery thereafter, and ignored an order of maintenance. When he subsequently sought divorce on the ground of non-resumption of cohabitation, the Supreme Court refused relief, because the wrong contemplated by Section 23(1)(a) must be of a grave and weighty character and his persistent misconduct was of that kind. The decision also settled that mere non-compliance with a decree does not by itself disentitle a petitioner.

    Condonation is forgiveness of the matrimonial offence by a petitioner who knows of it, together with reinstatement of the guilty spouse in the former position. Reinstatement is most readily inferred from resumed cohabitation, particularly sexual intercourse. Section 23(1)(b) names condonation, with connivance, for the adultery ground, and in N.G. Dastane v. S. Dastane (AIR 1975 SC 1534) the Supreme Court applied it to a petition founded on cruelty. Condonation is conditional: if the condoned spouse commits a further matrimonial offence, the condoned wrong revives.

    Connivance is a bar under Section 23(1)(b) only when the ground is adultery. It is corrupt, anticipatory consent: knowing complicity in circumstances likely to lead to adultery. Mere negligence or inattention is not connivance, but deliberately creating the opportunity is.

    Collusion, in Section 23(1)(c), is a secret understanding between the parties to deceive the court, by suppressing facts, fabricating evidence or presenting a false case. Even in an undefended case the court must inquire whether collusion exists. Section 23(1)(bb) adds, for a petition under Section 13B, that the consent must not have been obtained by force, fraud or undue influence.

    Section 23(1)(d) bars relief where there has been unnecessary or improper delay in instituting the proceedings. Delay alone is not enough; it must be unreasonable and unexplained in the circumstances of the parties. The courts have accepted explanations such as the stigma of divorce, the interests of children or the marriage prospects of siblings. Where the petitioner has simply held the remedy in reserve, the court will refuse relief.

    The Duty of Reconciliation

    Before granting relief, Section 23(2) requires the court to make every endeavour to bring about a reconciliation, wherever that is possible consistently with the nature and circumstances of the case. The duty does not apply where the ground is conversion, unsound mind, venereal disease, renunciation of the world or presumption of death, since reconciliation is impractical there. Leprosy was formerly in this list and has gone with the 2019 amendment. A failure to attempt reconciliation does not go to the court's jurisdiction.

    The Residuary Bar

    Section 23(1)(e) contains a residuary provision: there must be "no other legal ground why relief should not be granted." It is a residual clause that lets the court refuse relief where some other statutory condition is not met or a legal ground against relief exists outside the named bars.

    In sum, proof of a ground is only the first step, and the court may still refuse relief if a bar under Section 23 applies.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.