Can the court adjudicate upon the bar of limitation though the written statement does not raise that issue?
The court can and must do so. Section 3(1) makes it the duty of the court to dismiss a suit, appeal or application that is out of time, and it does so in terms that do not depend on any objection by the other side. The question for the court is not whether the defendant has raised the point but whether the proceeding was filed in time.
The duty applies at every stage. It is not confined to the trial court but extends to the appellate courts, and a party who did not raise the point below may raise it in appeal. In State of Gujarat v Kothari and Associates ((2016) 14 SCC 761) the Supreme Court held that it was incumbent on the court to satisfy itself that the suit was not barred, regardless of whether the plea had been raised, and that the State was entitled to raise the point on appeal. The Andhra Pradesh High Court in Pyda Subbaramayya Chetty v Premier Bank of India Ltd (AIR 1959 AP 96) took the position that, even where the defendant has not pleaded limitation, the court must satisfy itself that the suit is barred on facts established on the evidence. The Orissa High Court in Sheikh Makbul v Union of India (AIR 1960 Ori 146) described section 3 as imperative, and the Kerala High Court's decision in Craft Centre v Koncherry Coir Factories (AIR 1991 Ker 83) is to the same effect. The Code of Civil Procedure supports this by Order VII Rule 11(d), which requires the court to reject a plaint when the suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law. If the bar is plain from the plaint, the court need not wait for a written statement at all.
The duty has limits. The court acts on the law applied to facts that are before it. The bar must appear from the plaint, or from facts that are admitted or proved. Limitation is often a mixed question of law and fact, and where evidence is needed an issue is framed and tried in the ordinary way. In Banarasi Das v Kanshi Ram (AIR 1963 SC 1165) it was held that a plea of limitation involving mixed questions of fact and law is not to be allowed to be raised for the first time in argument, and such a plea likewise cannot be raised for the first time in second appeal if it would call for additional evidence. The court must also be sure of the date from which time runs. It cannot dismiss a suit on an assumption.
Nor can the parties take the matter out of the court's hands. A party's silence, consent or even express agreement does not prevent the court from acting under section 3.
Consider an example. A sues B for a loan of two lakh rupees advanced on 10 June 2022, and the plaint is dated 12 August 2025. B's written statement denies the loan but says nothing about limitation. The court must nevertheless look at Article 19, which gives three years from the date of the loan, see that the plaint was presented two months after the period expired, and dismiss the suit. B's silence does not help A. The position would be different if A had pleaded facts that bring him within sections 14, 17, 18 or 19, in which case the court would have to examine those facts before dismissing. Section 5 would not help him, since it does not apply to suits.
The conclusion is that the court not only may but must decide the bar of limitation on its own motion, provided the facts needed to decide it are properly before it.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
