Discuss if a deed of dower by a Muslim husband in favour of his wife transferring to her immovable property of the value of Rs. 10,000 in lieu of satisfaction of the dower debt due to her requires registration.
A dower deed that only fixes the debt needs no registration, but one that transfers immovable property in satisfaction of dower is a sale and must be registered.
A dower deed records the husband's liability to pay a sum to the wife under Muslim law. Whether it must be registered depends on what the document does. A document that only acknowledges a liability to pay money, not secured on immovable property, does not touch section 17. A document that transfers immovable property to the wife in satisfaction of the dower does.
Dower as a debt. Under Muslim law, dower (mahr) is a sum or other property the wife is entitled to on marriage. When it is unpaid it is a debt owed by the husband, and it can be recovered as a debt. The widow also has the right to retain possession of the husband's property until the dower is paid, a right that does not by itself make her an owner. A written promise to pay the dower in money is not an instrument that creates a right in immovable property, and section 17(1)(b) is not attracted.
Transfer in lieu of dower. The position changes when the husband conveys immovable property to the wife in discharge of the dower. Such a transfer, made for consideration in the form of the dower debt, is in nature a sale, and in Muslim law a hiba-bil-iwaz, a gift for consideration, which is treated like a sale. A sale of immovable property of the value of one hundred rupees or more requires a registered instrument under section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, and the document is compulsorily registrable under section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act. If it is not registered, section 49 prevents it from affecting the property, and it cannot be received as evidence of the transaction.
Why the oral-gift cases do not help. Section 129 of the Transfer of Property Act saves the rules of Muslim law on gifts, so a plain hiba of immovable property can be made orally with delivery of possession (Hafeeza Bibi v Shaikh Farid, (2011) 5 SCC 654). That principle covers gifts made without consideration. A transfer made in satisfaction of dower is not a plain gift, because the wife gives up a debt as the price. It is treated as a transaction for consideration, and the exemption for oral gifts therefore does not apply to it.
Summary. A deed that merely acknowledges or fixes the dower needs no registration. A deed that conveys immovable property worth one hundred rupees or more to the wife in satisfaction of her dower must be registered. Where it is not, the wife may still be able to rely on her lien, her right to retain possession, and a suit to recover the dower debt.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
