Discuss the circumstances in which registration of a document can be refused by the Registering Authority. What is the remedy against an unjustified refusal?
A Sub-Registrar must refuse where there is a defect of presentation, time, form or denial of execution, but not for want of proof of the vendor title.
A registering officer must register a document that is duly presented and executed, but the Act lists grounds on which he may or must refuse. These are best grouped by the stage at which the defect arises.
Defects in presentation. The officer refuses when the document is presented at the wrong office, since section 28 requires presentation in the sub-district where the property lies; when it is presented by a person who is not entitled to present it under section 32; when it is out of time and neither section 24, 25 nor 26 applies (section 23); or when the property is not described as the Act requires (sections 21 and 22), or interlineations, blanks and alterations are not attested as section 20 requires. A document in a language not commonly used in the district, and without a translation or a true copy as section 19 requires, may also be refused.
Defects in execution. When a person executing the document denies the execution, the Sub-Registrar must refuse to register as to that person (section 35(3)). The same applies if the person appears to be a minor, of unsound mind, or if the executant has died and his representative or assign denies execution. If the executant does not appear before the officer, registration cannot proceed as to him unless compelled by summons (sections 34 to 36).
Payment and stamping. A document that is insufficiently stamped is not refused outright; the officer impounds it and sends it to the Collector, as the Stamp Act, 1899 provides, and the presentation remains a good presentation though registration is delayed. Registration fees have to be paid.
What is not a ground. The Sub-Registrar cannot refuse because the vendor's title is not proved or because he doubts the validity of the transaction. The Supreme Court has said that section 35 gives the registering authority no quasi-judicial power (Satya Pal Anand v State of M.P., (2016) 10 SCC 767), and that registration cannot be refused for want of proof of the vendor's title, a rule to that effect having been struck down as outside the Act (K. Gopi v Sub-Registrar, 2025 INSC 462, 7 April 2025).
Recording reasons. Under section 71(1), a Sub-Registrar who refuses to register, except because the property is not within his sub-district, must make an order of refusal, record his reasons in Book No. 2, endorse "registration refused" on the document and, on application, give a free copy of his reasons. A document so endorsed cannot be accepted again unless a direction to register is made under the Act (section 71(2)).
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
