Constitutional LawUnion and State Judiciary 03 August 2026· 3 min read

    Discuss the powers of President to consult Supreme Court under Article 143 of the Constitution. Whether the Supreme Court can decline to answer a reference? Explain.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Article 143 gives the President two powers to consult the Supreme Court.

    Clause (1). If it appears to the President that a question of law or fact has arisen or is likely to arise, and that it is of such a nature and of such public importance that it is expedient to obtain the Supreme Court's opinion, he may refer it to the Court. The Court, after such hearing as it thinks fit, may report its opinion to the President. Two conditions must be satisfied: a question of law or fact that has arisen or may arise, and its nature and public importance, which make it expedient to seek the opinion. The satisfaction of the President on these two counts justifies the reference (Keshav Singh's case, AIR 1965 SC 745). The power is wide. It is not limited to questions arising in the President's own functions, nor to the subjects in the Union List or Concurrent List, and it can be used before a Bill is passed, as in Re Kerala Education Bill, AIR 1958 SC 956, where the Court rejected the objection that the reference concerned a Bill that was yet to be enacted. If the President refers only some questions about a Bill, the Court will not decline to answer for that reason: it is for the President to decide what should be referred, and the Court cannot go beyond the reference. In his decision the President acts on the advice of the Cabinet.

    Clause (2). A matter that is excluded from the Court's jurisdiction under Article 131 may be referred to the Court for its opinion, and here the Court "shall" report.

    Limits on the power. The President cannot use the reference to get the Court to reconsider its earlier decisions. The Court has said that it has no appellate jurisdiction over itself, and that to allow the executive to ask the Court to revise its own decision would be a serious inroad on judicial independence. The reference has to concern a question not already decided.

    Can the Court decline? The answer is yes, in a proper case, as far as Article 143(1) goes. The word "may" shows that the Court is not constitutionally obliged to answer every reference. It can decline for strong and compelling reasons, for instance where the question is socio-economic or political with no constitutional significance, where it is hypothetical or too general or vague, or where it is not proper or possible to answer it. The Court then returns the reference after pointing out the impediment. This was done in Re Special Courts Bill, AIR 1979 SC 478, which describes the Court's duty to consider the question referred and to report, but allows it to return a reference it cannot answer. Most notably, in Special Reference No 1 of 1993 (the Ram Janmabhumi reference), the majority declined because the matter was already the subject of litigation in the lower courts, so that the reference was superfluous and unnecessary. Ahmadi J and Bharucha J, concurring, said that the Court may decline when it considers that it is not proper or possible to answer, but must give reasons, and they also thought that the reference favoured one religious community over another and so was opposed to secularism. Under Article 143(2), because of the word "shall", the Court has to give its opinion.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.