Discuss with the help of decided cases the protection that Article 311 accords to Civil Services.
Background. In Britain a civil servant holds office at the pleasure of the Crown and can be dismissed at will, without reasons or notice and without any right to sue. Article 310(1) adopts the rule: defence personnel, civil servants of the Union and members of an All-India Service hold office during the pleasure of the President, and a civil servant of a State during the pleasure of the Governor. The justification is public policy, so that inefficient, dishonest or corrupt persons need not be kept in service. The power to make rules on conditions of service under Article 309 is itself subject to Article 310. But Article 310 begins with the words "except as expressly provided by this Constitution", and Article 311 is such an express provision [UOI v Tulsiram Patel, AIR 1985 SC 1416]. The pleasure doctrine is also limited by the Fundamental Rights, so that a dismissal cannot be discriminatory (Articles 14, 15 and 16), by the requirement of consultation with the Public Service Commission in disciplinary matters [Article 320(3)(c)], and by the Constitution's provisions for the security of tenure of certain officers, such as the judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts.
Article 311(1): the dismissing authority. No civil servant may be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate to the one that appointed him. The aim is to give security against dismissal by subordinate authorities in whose judgment the servant may have little faith. It does not restrict the President or Governor, who may dismiss any servant. The dismissing authority need not be the appointing authority itself, but only of the same or coordinate rank. A person appointed by a Secretary cannot be dismissed by a Deputy Secretary, and a rule that lets a junior officer dismiss employees appointed by a senior authority is invalid. The guarantee relates only to the order of dismissal. In State of Madhya Pradesh v Shardul Singh, (1970) 1 SCC 108, the Supreme Court held that the inquiry may be started and conducted by a subordinate officer so long as the dismissal is by the proper authority.
Article 311(2): the right to an inquiry. No civil servant may be dismissed, removed or reduced in rank except after an inquiry in which he has been informed of the charges and given a reasonable opportunity of being heard. This applies only to the three major penalties. Minor penalties such as censure and withholding of increments are outside it.
When does Article 311(2) apply? The Court has examined what counts as dismissal, removal or reduction in rank. A person substantively appointed to a permanent post acquires the right to hold it until superannuation, and termination of his service is punishment, so Article 311(2) applies. A rule allowing termination of permanent employees by notice or by pay in lieu of notice is invalid. A temporary employee has no right to the post, and termination simpliciter by notice does not attract Article 311(2). But if the order casts a stigma or visits evil consequences on him, or if it follows a formal inquiry into misconduct, it is punitive and the protection applies. In Madan Gopal v State of Punjab, AIR 1963 SC 531, a temporary employee was discharged after an inquiry found him guilty of bribery, and the order was quashed for want of compliance with Article 311(2). The Court looks beyond the wording of the order to see whether misconduct is its foundation [Parshotam Lal Dhingra v UOI, AIR 1958 SC 36]. Words such as "unsuitable" or "unfit" are not a stigma. Abolition of a post is not dismissal, unless it is done mala fide as a cloak for penal action. Reduction from a higher to a lower rank is covered where the servant has a right to the rank, or where it carries penal consequences such as loss of seniority, a stigma or an inquiry preceding it. An officiating appointee reverted without such consequences is not protected.
What is a reasonable opportunity? Article 311(2) requires the application of natural justice, though the content varies with the facts and it is for the courts to say whether the opportunity was reasonable. The principles the Court has laid down include clear and specific charges; communication of the evidence and supply of documents; an effective hearing, with the chance to cross-examine witnesses and to lead evidence; a decision based on some evidence and not on secret material; and personal hearing on demand. Before December 1976 a second opportunity to show cause against the proposed penalty had to be given after the inquiry. The Forty-second Amendment abolished it. But the Court has held that a copy of the inquiry report must be furnished to the servant before the disciplinary authority decides [UOI v Mohd Ramzan Khan, AIR 1991 SC 471; Managing Director, ECIL v B Karunakar, AIR 1994 SC 1074], and that non-supply will vitiate the order only if prejudice is shown. If the disciplinary authority disagrees with a finding in the servant's favour, it must give him an opportunity first [Punjab National Bank v Kunj Behari Misra, AIR 1998 SC 2713].
Exceptions. The second proviso to Article 311(2) removes the right to an inquiry in three cases: - (a) where the servant is dismissed on conduct that led to his conviction on a criminal charge. The authority must consider the conduct, the gravity of the offence and extenuating circumstances, and can act on the conviction, without waiting for the appeal [Nagoor Meera]. The penalty may be struck down if arbitrary or grossly disproportionate [Shankar Dass v India]; - (b) where the authority, for reasons recorded in writing, is satisfied that it is not reasonably practicable to hold an inquiry. The decision must rest on objective facts and not on whim, and cannot be taken merely because the department's case is weak. In Jaswant Singh, an order was quashed where the stated reason, that the witnesses might be insulted or attacked, was held irrelevant and insufficient; - (c) where the President or Governor is satisfied that, in the interest of the security of the State, it is not expedient to hold an inquiry. The satisfaction is that of the President or Governor in the constitutional sense, acting through the Rules of Business. It is subjective, and no reasons need to be recorded, but the order is open to review on the grounds of mala fides or extraneous or irrelevant considerations, and the government must place before the court the material on which the satisfaction was based, subject to privilege.
In Tulsiram Patel the Court held that natural justice cannot be read into these three cases, because the second proviso expressly excludes Article 311(2). The decision strengthened the government's power against grave misconduct, with limited judicial review and a departmental appeal as safeguards. Under Article 311(3) the decision of the authority that an inquiry is not reasonably practicable is final, provided it is made in the manner laid down.
Remedies. The Court has held that a dismissed servant whose dismissal is found unlawful may claim arrears of salary, whatever the English rule [State of Bihar v Abdul Majid]. Service tribunals under Article 323A, such as the Central Administrative Tribunal, hear service disputes. They act in a supervisory role, and cannot reappreciate the evidence in a disciplinary matter and substitute their own conclusion.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
