Doctor A employed Doctor B for 3 years with agreement that after termination, B shall not practice within 3 kms for 3 years or pay Rs. 50,000 as liquidated damages. B started practice next door. A sues for Rs. 50,000. Decide
Agreement in Restraint of Trade (Section 27)
Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, states that "Every agreement by which anyone is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind, is to that extent void". This section declares every such agreement void and does not allow any distinction between a total restraint or a partial restraint.
Courts have traditionally viewed such restraints unfavourably, believing that the public interest requires individuals to be free to engage in employment or practice their profession. Such a restraint is also usually not in the best interests of the individual being restrained. Agreements to restrain a servant or employee from competing with the employer after the termination of employment may not be allowed by the courts, unless the restraint is necessary for protecting the employer's goodwill. However, Zaheer Khan v. Percept D. Mark (India) Pvt Ltd (AIR 2004 Bom. 362) which held that a contract restricting a party's future liberty to carry on affairs as they like and with persons they choose would be an unreasonable restraint of trade and hit by Section 27.
In the scenario provided, the agreement restrains Dr. B from practising within a specific area (3 kms) and for a specific period (3 years) after the termination of his employment with Dr. A. Based on the strict interpretation of Section 27 in India, which voids both total and partial restraints, and the principle that post-termination restraints are generally not allowed, this agreement restraining Dr. B from practising is likely void under Section 27 as being against public policy which favours freedom of profession.
Liquidated Damages Clause (Section 74)
The agreement also stipulates that Dr. B shall pay Rs. 50,000 as liquidated damages if he breaches the restraint. This aspect of the agreement falls under Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, which deals with compensation for breach of contract where a sum is named as payable in case of breach.
Section 74 provides that when a contract is broken, if a sum is named in the contract as the amount to be paid in case of such breach, the party complaining of the breach is entitled to receive from the party who has broken the contract reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount so named.
An illustration is directly relevant: "A contracts with B that if A practices as a surgeon within Calcutta, he will pay B Rs. 5,000. A practices as surgeon in Calcutta. B is entitled to such compensation, not exceeding Rs. 5,000 as the court considers reasonable". This shows that Section 74 can apply to agreements restricting professional practice with a named sum for breach.
While Section 74 dispenses with the strict requirement of proving the exact amount of actual damage or loss, it does not justify the award of compensation when no legal injury has resulted. The compensation awarded must be reasonable and should be for the loss or damage caused by the breach. Damages are compensatory, not penal. The court has to ascertain the reasonableness of the amount.
Application to the Scenario:
When Dr. A sues for Rs. 50,000:
The primary legal challenge for Dr. A is likely to be the validity of the restraint clause itself under Section 27. Since post-termination restraints are generally void, a court may hold the entire clause (including the promise not to practice and the linked damages) as void and unenforceable. If the restraint is void, there is no enforceable obligation for Dr. B not to practice, and consequently, no breach giving rise to a claim for damages under Section 74.
However, if the court were to consider the restraint clause enforceable (perhaps under an exception) and finds that Dr. B has breached it by practising next door, then Section 74 would apply to the claim for Rs. 50,000. Dr. A would not automatically be entitled to the full Rs. 50,000. Instead, Dr. A would be entitled to reasonable compensation for the loss suffered due to Dr. B's breach of the restraint, and this reasonable compensation cannot exceed the stipulated amount of Rs. 50,000. Dr. A would need to demonstrate that they suffered some legal injury as a result of Dr. B practicing nearby.
In conclusion, while the agreement names a sum for the breach, its enforceability is contingent on the validity of the underlying restraint clause under Section 27. Given the nature of the post-termination restraint on professional practice, it is likely to be held void under Section 27. Even if enforceable, Dr. A would only be entitled to reasonable compensation, not exceeding Rs. 50,000, under Section 74.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
