Electrical company contracted with fertilizer company for transformer supply at firm price. Due to petroleum price hike, transformer oil prices increased 400%. Can supplier back out?
The core issue here is whether the drastic increase in the cost of performing the contract due to the petroleum price hike constitutes a ground for the supplier (electrical company) to be excused from performance under the doctrine of frustration, or if it is merely a case of commercial hardship.
General Principle: Commercial Hardship vs. Frustration
There is a distinction between performance becoming impossible and performance merely becoming difficult or unprofitable. The doctrine of frustration, covered under Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, applies when an act becomes impossible or unlawful after the contract is made, rendering the contract void.
However, it is clear that commercial hardship is generally not a ground for frustration.
"merely because the procurement of the goods become difficult due to mill strike, or there is a rise in prices... is not enough to frustrate the contract".
"Disappointed expectations do not amount to frustration".
A "wholly abnormal rise or fall in prices... does not in itself affect the bargain they have made".
There is "no general liberty reserved to the courts to absolve a party from liability... when the performance of the contract had become merely onerous".
Cases involving price increases due to enhanced duties are treated as "commercial hardship" which makes performance "unprofitable or more expensive, but it is not sufficient to excuse performance". The supplier cannot take the plea of frustration in such a case.
Based on this general principle, a significant increase in the price of a component, making the contract much more expensive for the supplier, would typically be considered commercial hardship. The supplier would generally be bound to perform the contract despite the increased cost and would be liable for breach if they fail to do so.
The Specific Case of Abnormal Price Escalation: Easun Engg. Co. Ltd.
However, the relevant caselaw that appears to deal with an exceptional situation of extreme price increase in a firm price contract: Easun Engg. Co. Ltd. v Fertilizers & Chemicals Travancore Ltd. (AIR 1991 Mad. 158).
This case involved a contract for the supply of Power Transformers between Easun Engg. Co. and Fertilizers & Chemicals Travancore Ltd..
The contract was on a "firm price" basis, meaning the prices were fixed without any escalation until execution was complete.
Easun Co. failed to supply transformers due to a 400% increase in the cost of transformer oil caused by war conditions in the Middle East and Government of India's Ordinance imposing higher excise duties.
The contract included a "force majeure" clause which exempted liability for delay caused by events like strikes, war, government regulation, or any other cause beyond the parties' control.
Easun contended they were prevented from supplying due to these force majeure conditions, including the phenomenal increase in oil cost.
The Arbitrator concluded that, despite the firm price contract, Easun was justified in asking for a variation of price for the transformer oil in view of the force majeure conditions. The arbitrator also noted the force majeure clause exempted liquidated damages for delay.
The Madras High Court upheld the Arbitrator's award. The court observed that the 400% price increase was "very much abnormal" and "cannot be described as anything which would be normal in the ordinary trade conditions".
The court stated that "A contract ceases to exist if fundamentally different situation unexpectedly emerge".
Where there was a 400% escalation of prices owing to a war on a firm basis contract, "the contract was held to have ended (on account of frustration)".
Decision in the Present Scenario
General Rule: Ordinarily, a significant price increase making a contract more expensive would be considered commercial hardship, not frustration. Under the general rule, the supplier would likely be in breach for failing to supply at the firm price. The later decision in Energy Watchdog v CERC (2017) 14 SCC 80 reaffirms that a rise in the cost of performance, without more, does not frustrate a contract, so Easun should be treated with caution.
Exception from Easun Case: However, the Easun Engg. Co. Ltd. case, which involved a very similar situation: a firm price contract and an abnormal (400%) price increase in a key component due to war/government action. In that specific case, the court upheld a finding that this abnormal increase justified non-performance at the original price or seeking a price variation, and interpret this as the contract ending by frustration.
Contract Interpretation: The outcome could depend heavily on the specific terms of the contract, particularly if it includes a force majeure clause and how that clause is worded and interpreted in light of the Easun precedent. If the clause covers events like war, government action, or other causes beyond control, an argument can be made that the 400% price hike triggered by war and government ordinance falls under this clause, potentially excusing performance at the original price or allowing for negotiation as suggested by the arbitrator's decision in Easun.
Conclusion:
While a standard price increase is usually treated as commercial hardship and does not excuse performance, the extraordinary 400% price hike in a key component in this scenario is analogous to the situation in Easun Engg. Co. Ltd. v Fertilizers & Chemicals Travancore Ltd.. In that case, the court found that such an abnormal increase could lead to a "fundamentally different situation" and upheld the justification for non-performance at the original price, with the contract ended by frustration.
Therefore, B (the fertilizer company) suing for damages for breach of contract might not succeed if the court follows the precedent set out in Easun Engg. Co. Ltd. as described, finding that the contract was discharged by frustration under Section 56 due to the unforeseen and abnormal price escalation creating a fundamentally different situation.
If the contract is found to be frustrated, it becomes void, and neither party can sue for damages for the non-performance caused by the frustrating event. However, if any advance payment was made, it might be recoverable under Section 65, which deals with the restoration of advantages received under a contract that becomes void.
If, despite the Easun case, the court treats this as mere commercial hardship, then the supplier would be in breach, and B could sue for damages under Section 73, typically based on the difference between the contract price and the market price [Section 73, Illustration (a), 45, 106].
However, given the direct parallel and the specific outcome reported in the Easun case, the more likely outcome, is that the supplier can back out (or be excused from performing at the original price) on the ground of frustration or due to the operation of a force majeure clause covering such events, and B's suit for damages for breach would fail.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
