"Every person is competent to contract who is of the age of majority according to the law of which he is subject..."
The statement, "Every person is competent to contract who is of the age of majority according to the law to which he is subject...", is a key principle in the law of contract concerning the capacity of parties to enter into a legally binding agreement. This principle is enshrined in Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
According to Section 11, a person is competent to contract if they satisfy three conditions:
They are of the age of majority according to the law to which they are subject.
They are of sound mind.
They are not disqualified from contracting by any law to which they are subject.
The age of majority in India is generally eighteen years under the Majority Act, 1875 (S.3). However, the age is twenty-one years if a guardian of the minor's person or property has been appointed by the court. The relevant law to determine the age of majority is the law to which the individual is subject.
Nature and Effects of a Minor's Agreement
Section 10 of the Contract Act requires parties to be competent to contract, and Section 11 specifies who is competent. Neither of these sections explicitly stated whether an agreement made by a minor would be voidable at their option or altogether void. However, following the landmark decision by the Privy Council in the case of Mohoribibi v Dharmodas Ghose [(1903) 30 Cal 539], it is now well-settled that a minor's agreement is absolutely void (void ab initio).
Leading Case: Mohoribibi v Dharmodas Ghose In this case, a minor mortgaged his house to a money-lender to secure a loan. The money-lender's attorney had information that the plaintiff was a minor. The minor subsequently sued to have the mortgage cancelled on the ground that he was underage when he executed it. The money-lender sought repayment of the portion of the loan that had been advanced.
The Privy Council held that the agreement made by the minor was absolutely void as against him. They reasoned that under Indian law, a minor is incapable of giving consent, and where there is no consent, there can be no contract. Section 64 of the Contract Act, which requires a party rescinding a voidable contract to restore any benefit received, was held not to apply to a minor's agreement because it is absolutely void, not merely voidable. The Court emphasized that the policy of the law is to protect minors, not only from unscrupulous persons but also from their own actions.
As a consequence of a minor's agreement being void ab initio, no contractual obligation can be enforced against the minor. The effects of such an agreement must be determined independently of contract law.
While a minor's agreement is void, this does not mean that a minor can never be involved in transactions or incur any form of liability. The several important nuances and exceptions:
Beneficial Contracts: The rule that a minor's contract is void primarily applies when the minor is charged with obligations. A minor is not debarred from accepting a benefit and can enforce a contract which is of some benefit to them and under which they are not required to bear an obligation. For example, a minor can sue to enforce a mortgage where they have advanced the full mortgage money, be a promisee, or purchase immovable property. Contracts for the marriage of a minor may also be enforceable against the other party at the instance of the minor. Contracts of apprenticeship under the Apprentices Act, 1961 are also binding on minors if they are beneficial.
Liability for Necessaries (Section 68): Although a minor's agreement is void and they are not personally liable, their estate is liable for necessaries supplied to them or to anyone they are legally bound to support. This liability is not based on contract but is considered a quasi-contractual obligation. The supplier is entitled to be reimbursed from the property of the minor, but the minor is not personally liable. Section 68 specifically covers this situation, distinguishing it from Section 70 which excludes minors.
Restitution (Under Specific Relief Act, 1963): While the Privy Council in Mohoribibi rejected restitution under the Contract Act for void contracts, Section 33(2)(b) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 provides an equitable remedy. Where a minor is a defendant in a case and resists the enforcement of a contract on the ground of minority, the court may require the minor to restore such benefits to the other party, to the extent that the minor or their estate has benefited. Compensation in terms of money is also permitted.
No Estoppel Against Minor: It is a well-settled principle that there is no estoppel against a minor, even if the minor misrepresented their age at the time of contracting. The minor is not prevented from later pleading the defence of minority. The law of estoppel (a rule of evidence) cannot be used to defeat the substantive law in the Contract Act that declares a minor's contract void. The policy protecting minors overrides the doctrine of estoppel.
Ratification: A person cannot ratify an agreement made during their minority upon attaining the age of majority. Ratification dates back to the time the contract was made, and a contract that was void then cannot be made valid later. If the parties wish to create a binding obligation after the minor attains majority, a fresh contract with fresh consideration is necessary. Consideration received during minority is not considered valid past consideration for a fresh promise upon attaining majority. However, if fresh consideration is provided after majority, a promise covering the prior debt and the new advance can be binding.
Tort Liability: While a minor is generally liable for torts, they are not liable for a tort that arises directly out of a contract. This is to prevent the enforcement of a void agreement indirectly. However, if the tort is independent of the contract, the minor may still be held liable.
In summary, the requirement for parties to be of the age of majority is a fundamental aspect of contractual capacity under Indian law. Agreements entered into by minors are generally considered absolutely void for their protection, as established in Mohoribibi v Dharmodas Ghose. Nevertheless, the law provides mechanisms such as the enforcement of beneficial contracts, liability for necessaries against the minor's estate, and the equitable power of courts under the Specific Relief Act that allow for certain consequences and protections despite the void nature of the minor's agreement.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
