Contract ActVoidable Contracts and Void Agreements 13 May 2026· 5 min read

    "Every restraint whether partial or general is contrary to public and prima facie void." Examine with reference to Section 27

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The principle that "Every restraint whether partial or general is contrary to public [policy] and prima facie void" is a central tenet relating to agreements in restraint of trade under the Indian Contract Act, 1872. This is primarily governed by Section 27.

    Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act states that "Every agreement by which anyone is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind, is to that extent void."

    Rationale and Public Policy: The underlying principle behind Section 27 is the protection of freedom of trade and commerce, which is considered a fundamental right under the Constitution of India. Public policy requires that every man shall be at liberty to work for himself and should not be allowed to deprive himself or the State of his labour, skill, or talent through a contract. Agreements restraining trade are generally seen as aiming at avoiding competition and having a monopolistic tendency, which is detrimental to both the individual and society's interest. This aligns with the common law view that certain contracts are invalid because they are contrary to the social or economic interests of the wider community, with public policy considerations outweighing the parties' freedom to contract. Agreements in restraint of trade are one category of contracts considered void at common law on public policy grounds. Courts have traditionally been reluctant to enforce such contracts as they restrict personal liberty and potentially deprive society of the skills of the restrained party.

    "Every Restraint Whether Partial or General": A significant aspect of Section 27 is its broad scope. Section 27 declares every agreement in restraint of trade as void. Unlike English law, which traditionally distinguishes between total and partial restraints and permits reasonable restraints, Indian law, as interpreted, generally makes no such distinction between a total restraint or a partial restraint.

    An early interpretation, drawing support from the absence of the word "absolutely" in Section 27 (a word used in Section 28 dealing with restraint of legal proceedings), led courts to conclude that the section was intended to prevent not merely a total restraint but also a partial restraint. This interpretation has been widely accepted, establishing that "The section has abolished the distinction between partial and total restraints of trade. Whether the restraint is general or partial, unqualified or qualified, if the agreement is in the nature of a restraint of trade, it is void".

    This means an agreement requiring a person not to trade within a certain area or for a fixed period is also considered void under this general rule.

    Consequences: Voidness: Agreements in restraint of trade are among those expressly declared to be void agreements. Being void, they are not enforceable by law.

    Exceptions: While the general rule is strict, Section 27 and judicial decisions recognize certain exceptions:

    1. Statutory Exception (Sale of Goodwill): The only exception explicitly mentioned in Section 27 itself relates to the sale of goodwill. A person who sells the goodwill of a business may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within specified local limits, so long as the buyer continues the business, provided the limits are reasonable.

    2. Judicially Created Exceptions: Indian courts have recognised other limited exceptions through interpretation. These often apply in specific contexts, such as restraints:

      • During Employment: Agreements preventing an employee from working elsewhere during the period of employment are generally held to be valid. However, a restraint operating after an employee leaves service is considered prima facie void unless it can be justified within the narrow exceptions, for instance, to protect trade secrets or confidential information. The Supreme Court has focused on restraints imposed on employees.

      • Partnership Agreements: Restraints imposed on partners under the Indian Partnership Act are also recognised exceptions.

    Caselaws Illustrating the Principle and Exceptions:

    • Madhub Chunder v Raj Coomar Doss (1874) 14 BLR 76: This early case is foundational to the interpretation that Section 27 prohibits both total and partial restraints, based on the difference in wording compared to Section 28.

    • Zaheer Khan v. Percept D. Mark (India) Pvt Ltd (AIR 2004 Bom. 362): The Bombay High Court held that a contract restricting a party's future liberty to carry on affairs as they like and with persons they choose would be a contract in restraint of trade and hit by Section 27.

    • Superintendence Co of India Ltd v Krishan Mur- (AIR 1980 SC 1717): The Supreme Court held that a restraint extending beyond the term of service is prima facie void and can only be justified if brought within the scope of an exception.

    • English Cases (Fitch v Dewes, Drake Personnel Ltd v Beddison): While English law applies a reasonableness test generally, the analysis in these cases regarding employee restraints (e.g., distance and duration restrictions for solicitors or employment agency staff) illustrates the factors (like protection of confidential information or trade secrets) courts consider when determining if a restraint could potentially be valid within an exception, even under the stricter Indian regime. Fitch v Dewes upheld a 7-mile restraint for a solicitor's clerk as necessary to prevent improper use of confidential information, while Drake Personnel Ltd v Beddison found a 25-mile restraint for an employment agency employee unreasonable and unnecessary for protecting trade secrets or client lists.

    • Later authorities: The Supreme Court considered the same line of cases in Percept D'Mark (India) Pvt Ltd v Zaheer Khan (2006) 4 SCC 227, and in Gujarat Bottling Co Ltd v Coca Cola Co (1995) 5 SCC 545 it held that a negative covenant operating during the subsistence of the agreement is not a restraint of trade within Section 27. Agreements that restrain competition may now also fall under Section 3 of the Competition Act, 2002.

    In essence, Section 27 establishes a broad rule rendering agreements in restraint of trade void, regardless of whether the restraint is total or partial. This strict stance, differing from the English common law approach, is tempered only by specific statutory and limited judicial exceptions, which must be clearly demonstrated to save the agreement from being void.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.