"Every suit instituted, appeal preferred, and application made after the period of limitation prescribed therefore... shall be dismissed".
The sentence quoted is the core of section 3(1), and it is best understood by taking its parts in turn. Its effect is that the Act sets a period for each kind of proceeding, that the court applies it of its own accord, and that a proceeding filed outside it is dismissed unless one of the saving provisions applies.
The first expression is "suit instituted". Section 3(2)(a) tells us when this is. In an ordinary case a suit is instituted when the plaint is presented to the proper officer, in the case of a pauper when his application for leave to sue as a pauper is made, and in the case of a claim against a company being wound up by the court when the claimant first sends in his claim to the official liquidator. The date does not move because the court fee is made good later. Section 3(2)(b) adds that a claim by way of set-off or counter-claim is treated as a separate suit, deemed instituted on the date of the suit in the case of a set-off and on the date the counter-claim is made in court in the case of a counter-claim.
An appeal is "preferred" when it is presented. Order XLI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires a memorandum of appeal to be presented to the court or to an officer appointed by it, and sending it by post is not ordinarily presentation in a civil appeal. Where a statute provides for an appeal to an authority, the relevant date is the date on which the memorandum reaches that authority and not the date it was posted (F.N. Roy v Collector of Customs, AIR 1957 SC 648). An application is "made" on presentation as well. An application by notice of motion in a High Court is made when it is presented to the proper officer of that court (s 3(2)(c)). The Third Division of the Schedule prescribes the periods for applications, with Article 137 as the residuary article giving three years from when the right to apply accrues, and Article 136 allows twelve years for execution of a decree from the time it becomes enforceable.
The words "prescribed period" must be read with section 2(j). That clause defines the "period of limitation" as the period prescribed for any suit, appeal or application by the Schedule and the "prescribed period" as the period of limitation computed in accordance with the Act. The prescribed period is therefore not the bare number of years in the Schedule but that number as extended or reduced by the exclusions of time in sections 4 to 24.
The words "shall be dismissed" mean that the court has no discretion. A time-barred suit is dismissed even if the defendant never mentions limitation, and for suits there is no power of condonation because section 5 does not apply to them. For appeals and applications section 5 is the only relief. It should be noted that a decree passed in a time-barred suit, though wrong, is not a nullity, since section 3 does not remove the jurisdiction of the court. The older view that it does is not correct.
Finally, the phrase "subject to the provisions contained in sections 4 to 24" covers twenty-one sections. Most of sections 4 to 22 are exceptions that may save a proceeding which looks late: closed courts (s 4), condonation of delay in appeals and applications (s 5), legal disability (ss 6 to 8), continuous running of time (s 9), trust property (s 10), exclusion of time (ss 12 to 15), death and fraud or mistake (ss 16 and 17), acknowledgment and payment (ss 18 to 20), new parties (s 21) and continuing wrongs (s 22). Section 11 says that suits on contracts made outside the territories to which the Act extends are governed by the periods in this Act, section 23 fixes when time starts for compensation for acts not actionable without special damage, and section 24 deals with computing time mentioned in instruments.
Three short examples show the rule at work. Suppose money is lent on 10 June 2022 and the lender sues on 12 August 2025. Article 19 gives three years from when the loan is made, so the period ended on 10 June 2025 and the plaint is two months late. The court dismisses the suit whether or not the defendant pleads limitation. (Article 37 would be wrong here, because it applies only to a promissory note or bond payable by instalments with an acceleration clause.) Suppose next that a new plaintiff is added to a suit by amendment. Under section 21(1) the suit is deemed to have been instituted by him on the date he was joined, unless the court is satisfied that the omission was a bona fide mistake, in which case an earlier date may be taken. Suppose finally that the last day for filing an appeal falls on a Sunday. Under section 4 the appeal may be filed on the day the court reopens, but the saving applies only if the court was closed on the last day, and under the Explanation a court counts as closed if it is closed during any part of its normal working hours on that day.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
