Contract ActFree Consent 12 May 2026· 7 min read

    Fraud under Indian Contract Act

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    Fraud is one of the factors that can vitiate or impair the freeness of consent in a contract. When consent to an agreement is caused by fraud, the agreement is a contract voidable at the option of the party whose consent was so caused.

    Definition and Provisions (Section 17):

    Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act defines "Fraud". According to this section, "Fraud" means and includes any of the following acts, committed by a party to a contract, or with his connivance, or by his agent, with intent to deceive another party thereto or his agent, or to induce him to enter into the contract:

    1. The suggestion, as a fact, of that which is not true, by one who does not believe it to be true. This is a positive false statement made with knowledge of its falsity or without belief in its truth.

    2. The active concealment of a fact by one having knowledge or belief of the fact. Unlike mere silence, this involves a deliberate action to hide a material fact. For example, in B.R Chowdhury v. Indian Oil Corpn Ltd (2004), concealment of the fact of previous employment under the Government for getting a dealership was held to be active concealment, allowing termination of the dealership.

    3. A promise made without any intention of performing it. An illustration is buying goods with the intention of not paying the price. Another case, Delhi Development Authority v Skipper Construction Co (P) Ltd (2000), involved collecting money for accommodation when the party knew they would not be able to perform the contract with all purchasers; this was held to be fraud creating liability outside the agreement.

    4. Any other act fitted to deceive. This broad category captures actions not explicitly listed but designed to mislead. In Ningawwa v. Byrappa Shiddappa (AIR 1968 SC 956), a husband persuaded his illiterate wife to sign documents by telling her they were adoption deeds when they were actually sale deeds of her property; this was considered an act fitted to deceive.

    5. Any such act or omission as the law specially declares to be fraudulent. An example given is the seller of immovable property's duty under the Transfer of Property Act to disclose material defects in the property or title.

    The various acts amounting to fraud are diverse, making a simple, precise definition difficult. Fraud requires deliberateness.

    Key Ingredients of Fraud:

    The essential elements to constitute fraud are:

    • The act must be committed by a party to the contract, someone with their connivance, or their agent. Fraud by a stranger does not affect contract validity.

    • There must be an intention to deceive the other party or induce them to enter the contract. As stated by the Supreme Court, deliberateness is emphasized.

    • There must be a representation or assertion, and it must be false. The party making it must know it is false or not believe it to be true.

    • The representation must relate to a fact, not a mere opinion or puffery.

    • Active concealment of a fact amounts to fraud.

    • The fraud must have actually deceived the other party and caused their consent. The party must have relied on the representation.

    Silence as Fraud:

    Ordinarily, mere silence as to facts likely to affect a person's willingness to enter into a contract is not fraud. The explanation to Section 17 also states this. However, there are crucial exceptions where silence does amount to fraud:

    • Duty to speak: When one party must depend on the good faith of the other, the latter is bound to speak. This applies to contracts of absolute or utmost good faith (uberrima fides). Contracts of insurance are prime examples, where the assured must disclose all material facts. In Mithoo Lal Nayak v LIC of India (AIR 1962 SC 814), an action for refund was not entertained where the plaintiff had to prove his own fraud (non-disclosure). London Assurance Co. v Mensal held that non-disclosure of other companies declining to insure a life amounted to fraud. Other contracts requiring full disclosure include family settlements, marriage, allotment of shares, sale of immovable property, and guarantee.

    • Silence equivalent to speech: Sometimes, silence is, in itself, equivalent to speech and can amount to fraud.

    Case Law Illustrations:

    • Ningawwa v. Byrappa Shiddappa (AIR 1968 SC 956): Illustrated fraud where an illiterate wife was deceived about the nature of the document she was signing.

    • B.R. Chowdhury v. Indian Oil Corpn Ltd (2004): Showcased active concealment as fraud.

    • Delhi Development Authority v Skipper Construction Co (P) Ltd (2000): Held that making promises for accommodation without the intention or ability to fulfill them constituted fraud.

    • Shri Krishna v Kurukshetra University (1976): Demonstrated a situation where non-disclosure was not deemed fraud because it was the other party's duty to verify the information. A candidate not mentioning short attendance was held not fraudulent as the University should have scrutinized forms.

    • Foster v MacKinnon (1869): A case where fraud induced a mistake about the nature of a document, giving rise to the defence of non est factum ('the mind did not go with the pen').

    Effect of Fraud:

    • A contract induced by fraud is a contract voidable at the option of the party whose consent was so caused. This means the deceived party has the choice to either affirm the contract or rescind (cancel) it.

    • Upon rescission, the party is generally required to restore any benefit received under the contract. Sections 19 and 19A (though 19A specifically mentions undue influence) govern the setting aside of such contracts. The court may set aside the contract absolutely or subject to terms and conditions.

    • Fraud, in addition to rendering the contract voidable, can also be a cause of action in tort for damages.

    When the Right to Avoid is Lost:

    The right to avoid a contract on the ground of fraud can be lost in several circumstances:

    • When the party whose consent was caused by fraudulent silence had the means of discovering the truth with ordinary diligence. This is the proviso to Section 19: it applies to misrepresentation and to silence that is fraudulent within the meaning of Section 17, but it does not protect a party whose fraud consists of an active misstatement or active concealment.

    • Where the party was not actually defrauded (i.e., their consent was not caused by the fraud).

    • Where a party, after becoming aware of the fraud, takes a benefit under the contract or affirms it in some other way.

    • Where an innocent third party, before the contract is rescinded, acquires an interest in the property involved for consideration.

    Distinction from Misrepresentation:

    The key differences between fraud and misrepresentation:

    • Intent: Fraud is an intentional wrong committed with intent to deceive, whereas misrepresentation may be quite innocent. A false representation made without knowing it to be false does not amount to fraud.

    • Remedy: While both render the contract voidable, fraud is also a tort, giving rise to an action for damages. Simple misrepresentation does not give rise to a tort action.

    • Defence: The defence of "means of discovering the truth by ordinary diligence" applies to misrepresentation and to fraud by silence.

    Fraudulent agreements may also be void under Section 23 if the consideration or object is deemed fraudulent.

    In essence, fraud under the Indian Contract Act is a deliberate act or omission intended to deceive and induce a party into a contract. Its definition is detailed in Section 17, covering positive misstatements, active concealment, and promises made without intent to perform, among others. While mere silence is generally not fraud, it becomes so when there is a duty to speak or when silence is equivalent to speech, particularly in contracts of utmost good faith. The consequence of fraud is that the contract is voidable at the option of the deceived party, who may also have a claim in tort for damages. However, the right to avoid the contract can be lost under specific conditions, notably if the truth could have been discovered with ordinary diligence (with caveats).

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.