How will the property of a Hindu male dying intestate devolve under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956?
The Governing Framework: Section 8
Section 8 lays down that the property of a male Hindu dying intestate shall devolve in the following order:
Firstly, upon the heirs specified in Class I of the Schedule
Secondly, if there is no Class I heir, upon the heirs in Class II of the Schedule
Thirdly, if there is no heir of either class, upon the agnates of the deceased
Lastly, if there is no agnate, upon the cognates of the deceased
If there is no heir of any of these kinds, the property goes to the Government under Section 29, which takes it subject to all the obligations and liabilities to which an heir would have been subject. Escheat arises only where there is no heir at all.
The scheme rests on propinquity, that is, preference according to nearness of relationship. The Act replaces the old Mitakshara and Dayabhaga categories of gotraja sapindas, samanodakas and bandhus.
First in Line, Class I Heirs
Class I heirs are preferential heirs, because the presence of even one of them excludes every heir in a lower category, and simultaneous heirs, because none excludes another.
The distribution among them follows Section 10, which operates on the principle of branches. The surviving sons, daughters and mother each take one share. The widow, or all widows together, takes one share. Where a son or daughter predeceased the intestate leaving children, those children take together the one share their parent would have taken, so distribution is per stirpes between branches and per capita within a branch. The details are in Q.27.
Second in Line, Class II Heirs
If not a single Class I heir survives the intestate, the property falls to Class II heirs, who are arranged across nine Entries. An heir in an earlier Entry excludes all those in later Entries, and the heirs in the same Entry share equally.
The father stands alone in Entry I. After him come, in successive entries, the son's daughter's son, son's daughter's daughter, brother and sister (Entry II); the daughter's grandchildren (Entry III); the children of brothers and sisters (Entry IV); the paternal grandparents (Entry V); the step-mother and brother's widow (Entry VI); the paternal uncle and aunt (Entry VII); the maternal grandparents (Entry VIII); and the maternal uncle and aunt (Entry IX).
One important qualification runs through the entire Class II structure: Section 18 prefers full blood to half blood where the relationship is otherwise the same. Under the Explanation to the Schedule, references to a brother or sister do not include a brother or sister by uterine blood, who may succeed only as a cognate.
Third in Line, Agnates
If no heir of Class I or II survives, the property passes to the deceased's agnates, those who are related to him by blood or adoption wholly through males, as defined in Section 3(1)(a). The sex of the heir does not matter; every link in the chain of relationship must be through males. So a father's brother's daughter is an agnate, but a father's sister's son is not, because a female (the father's sister) has intervened in the line.
The Act gives no list of agnates and sets no limit on remoteness. The order among them is fixed by Section 12, and Section 13 explains how degrees are counted. Rule 1 prefers the heir with fewer or no degrees of ascent. If the degrees of ascent are equal or absent, Rule 2 prefers the heir with fewer or no degrees of descent. If neither rule decides the matter, Rule 3 makes the heirs take together. For example, the intestate's brother's son's son (one degree of ascent, to the father, and three of descent) is preferred to the father's father's father (three degrees of ascent), because he has fewer degrees of ascent. Full blood is preferred to half blood where the relationship is otherwise the same.
Last Resort, Cognates
Only after every agnate fails does the property reach the cognates, those related to the intestate by blood or adoption but not wholly through males, meaning that at least one female appears somewhere in the chain of relationship. The maternal uncle, the sister's son, the mother's mother, all of these are cognates. The rules of preference and computation of degrees are the same as for agnates under Sections 12 and 13. An agnate, however remote, is preferred to any cognate.
Mode of Holding, Tenants-in-Common
Section 19 provides that when two or more heirs succeed together, they take the property per capita (not per stirpes, unless expressly provided) and as tenants-in-common, not joint tenants. Each heir holds a defined share that passes to his or her own heirs on death, and there is no survivorship. In Commissioner of Wealth-tax v. Chander Sen (AIR 1986 SC 1753; (1986) 3 SCC 567) the Supreme Court held that property inherited by a son from his father under Section 8 is his separate property and does not become coparcenary property in his hands as against his own sons. That decision has since been considered in Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar ((1987) 1 SCC 204), Bhanwar Singh v. Puran ((2008) 3 SCC 87) and Uttam v. Saubhag Singh ((2016) 4 SCC 68), which qualify it in some situations, so the rule should be stated with care.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
