Registration ActContract and Agreement 07 July 2026· 4 min read

    In 1985, Food Corporation of India invited offers from land-owners for construction of plinth and other facilities for storage purposes and after construction, to lease to FCI on rent for three years. B submitted offer. After negotiation, offer of B at negotiated rate was accepted and agreement dated 12.06.1986 was entered into. FCI took possession on 24.01.87, but served notice of vacation on 26.09.1988. B filed suit for damages for breach of contract. Main defence of FCI is that in absence of registered lease deed the parties were not bound by the period of lease as the agreement was unenforceable. Question is whether or not agreement dated 12.06.1986 required compulsory registration under section 17 of the Registration Act and what is its effect? Decide giving reasons.

    The Food Corporation agreement to build and then lease was executory, did not need registration and supports a suit for damages for breach.

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The agreement of 12 June 1986 between B and the Food Corporation of India did not itself create a lease, so it did not require compulsory registration, and it is enforceable as a contract. The defence that the parties are not bound by the period of lease for want of a registered lease deed therefore fails.

    What the agreement did. The Corporation invited offers from land-owners to build a plinth and facilities for storage, and, after construction, to lease the premises to it on rent for three years. B's offer was accepted and an agreement was made. The agreement was one to build and then to lease. It contemplated that a lease would be given when construction was complete. A document that gives only a right to demand a further document is outside section 17(1)(b), as section 17(2)(v) provides. In Food Corporation of India v Babulal Agrawal, (2004) 2 SCC 129, which arose on these facts, the Supreme Court held that the agreement was executory in character and did not need registration.

    The point on the definition of a lease. Section 2(7) of the Registration Act says a lease includes an agreement to lease. That does not make every agreement for a future lease registrable. The question is whether the document itself creates a present right of tenancy or only provides for one to be created later. An agreement in which the future lease is still to be granted, on terms to be settled by a formal deed, falls in the second class.

    Effect of possession and rent. The Corporation took possession on 24 January 1987. A tenant in possession under an unregistered or non-existent lease is treated as a tenant from month to month, whose tenancy can be ended by notice under section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Anthony v K.C. Ittoop & Sons, (2000) 6 SCC 394). The notice of vacation, served on 26 September 1988, could end that monthly tenancy, but the agreement also contained a promise by the Corporation to take the premises for three years.

    Remedy. Because the agreement is an enforceable contract that did not need registration, the Corporation's early withdrawal is a breach of it, and B is entitled to damages for the part of the three-year period for which the Corporation had agreed to take the premises. The defence of non-registration fails.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.