Constitutional LawUnion and State Legislature 03 August 2026· 3 min read

    Is certification of a Bill as Money Bill by the Deputy Speaker valid?

    Audio playback is not supported in this browser.

    The answer turns on who is entitled to certify and on what the Constitution says about the Deputy Speaker.

    What Article 110 says. The Speaker of the House of the People decides whether a Bill is a Money Bill, and that decision is final [Article 110(3)]. When the Bill is sent to the Rajya Sabha, or presented to the President for assent, the Speaker must endorse on it a certificate that it is a Money Bill [Article 110(4)]. The certificate is conclusive on the question whether the Bill is a Money Bill. Thus the Speaker is the only authority named for this purpose.

    The Deputy Speaker's position. The Deputy Speaker is chosen by the House along with the Speaker. When the office of Speaker is vacant, the Deputy Speaker performs the duties of that office. When the Speaker is absent from a sitting of the House, the Deputy Speaker acts as Speaker and presides, except when a resolution for the Speaker's own removal is under consideration [Article 95]. If the Deputy Speaker's office is also vacant, a member appointed by the President performs the Speaker's duties until one of the offices is filled.

    The result. Article 110 does not mention the Deputy Speaker, but Article 95 makes him the person who discharges the duties of the Speaker's office in the cases it describes. A certificate endorsed by the Deputy Speaker while he is performing the duties of the Speaker under Article 95 is therefore a certificate given by the authority that Article 110 contemplates, and ought to be valid. A Deputy Speaker who certifies when the Speaker is present and able to act has no such footing. The Constitution does not say in terms whether the Deputy Speaker may certify while the Speaker is present and able to act, and the decisions on Article 110 discussed here do not address the point, so what is said here follows from Articles 95 and 110.

    Judicial review. Whether the Speaker's or a Deputy Speaker's certificate can be challenged in court is a different question. In KS Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) v UOI, (2019) 1 SCC 1, the Constitution Bench held the Aadhaar Bill to be a Money Bill, with Sikri J holding that the decision of the Speaker is open to judicial review in certain circumstances. Ashok Bhushan J held that the finality in Article 110(3) does not prevent the Court from reviewing the Speaker's decision. It is not a mere matter of procedure protected by Article 122, and where a Bill does not satisfy the constitutional condition, the certificate cannot cure that. Chandrachud J held that the decision can be tested against constitutional principles such as basic structure and bicameralism. A more restrained view is also taken: there is a presumption of legality in favour of the Speaker's decision, the burden is on the person challenging it, and judicial review is restricted to cases of complete disregard of the constitutional scheme. Following Rojer Mathew v South Indian Bank Ltd, (2020) 6 SCC 1, the scope of Article 110(1) has been referred to a larger bench.

    A certificate by the Deputy Speaker would therefore be open to challenge on the same grounds as the Speaker's, namely that the Bill contains matters beyond those in clauses (a) to (g) of Article 110(1), which means it is not a Money Bill, and that the certificate cannot make it one.

    Share:WhatsAppXLinkedIn

    Get weekly legal insights

    Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.