M/s Jameson & Co advertised in newspaper about Clearance Sale. C picks up a shirt with price tag of Rs. 400/-, but salesman discovers it should have been in Rs. 600/- lot and refuses to sell. Can C compel the firm to sell at Rs. 400/-?
This question also deals with Offer and Invitation to Offer:
Distinction between Offer and Invitation to Offer: In contract law, a crucial distinction exists between an offer (or proposal) and an invitation to offer (sometimes called an invitation to treat). An offer is made with the intention of creating a binding contract if accepted. An invitation to offer, on the other hand, is merely an expression of willingness to negotiate or receive offers.
Display of Goods with Price Tags: The display of goods in a shop with price tags attached is generally considered an invitation to offer, not a binding offer. This is true even in self-service shops. Similarly, advertisements of goods for sale, such as in a newspaper or brochure, are typically invitations to treat.
Customer's Action is the Offer: In this context, the customer (C) who picks up an article makes the offer to buy that article at the indicated price. The shopkeeper (or salesman) then has the liberty to accept or reject this offer.
Application to the Scenario:
M/s Jameson & Co's advertisement in the newspaper and the display of goods with price tags in their shop constituted an invitation to offer, not an offer to sell the shirt at Rs. 400.
When C picked up the shirt with the Rs. 400 price tag, C was making an offer to purchase the shirt for that price.
The salesman's action of discovering the correct price and refusing to sell at Rs. 400 amounted to a rejection of C's offer.
No Binding Contract Formed: Since the shopkeeper did not accept C's offer, no contract was formed between C and M/s Jameson & Co. A shopkeeper may refuse to sell for various reasons, such as limited stock. An incorrect price tag is also a valid reason for the shopkeeper to decline the customer's offer to buy at that mistaken price.
Relevant Case Laws:
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists (Southern) Ltd (1953): This leading case, held that the display of goods in a shop with price tags is merely an invitation to offer. The customer makes the offer at the counter, which the shopkeeper is free to accept or reject.
McPherson v Appana (AIR 1951 SC 184): Although concerning property, this case, in the context of invitation to offer, held that a mere statement of the lowest price does not imply a contract to sell at that price to the person making the inquiry. The court held that merely stating a price was inviting offers, not making one.
Harvey v Facey (1893) AC 552: Relied upon in McPherson v Appana and cited independently, this case established that merely providing the lowest cash price in response to an inquiry is not an offer to sell, but merely providing information.
Partridge v Crittenden (1968): Cited for the principle that a classified advertisement is not an offer to sell, but an invitation to treat. This supports the general idea that commercial communications listing prices are usually not offers.
Therefore, based on the principle that display of goods is an invitation to offer, C's action was an offer which the firm was entitled to refuse. C cannot legally compel M/s Jameson & Co to sell the shirt at the wrongly tagged price of Rs. 400.
Get weekly legal insights
Case-law digests, exam tips & curated study guides — straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
